HP: Black Rose, She Shines Like Stars

Really well written! The writing is also good. The protagonist of the Gerdeng period participates in the plot of the next generation and makes up for the regrets of the past. The protagonist has his own ambitions and emotional lines, will not embarrass the academy, and is friendly to badgers (badgers are the cutest!) I hope some typos can be corrected

Although it is Lalang CP, because the plot arrangement is very reasonable, it does not have the sense of absurdity of Lalang at all! Instead, there is a sense of logic and rationality. The characterization of the wife is really great!

Not bad. The character design, plot and details are all very good. The only thing I don't like is that the sub-CP content is too high. It's a bit troublesome for people like me who don't watch BL. It would be better if the content of the Lily line was higher. I don't have to say anything about the career line [Like][Like][Like]

Highly recommended. At first, I thought it was the kind of person who was too mindlessly abusive and too group-loving, or someone who was very abusive at first but then became highly praised. Later I found out it was a treasure. 1. The heroine Wenda has a super high IQ, is calm and calm, and doesn't panic in times of trouble. His personality is elegant, noble and crazy. 2. He also wrote that Albus and Grindelwald understand each other. 3. The writing is not a novice, the logic is delicate and clear, and it is not a brainless whitewash for Slytherin, but gives them a third way. The most important thing is that this article has two female protagonists. Friends who like to watch Lily can give it a try. 4. The author is really great.

Very creative and beautiful! At first, I thought it was something very ordinary, too sadistic or too group-loving, or maybe it was sadistic at first, but then it became more flattering later on. As a result, I saw a super, super, super, super, super, beautiful book that cannot be described in words! Hope more people can see it!

Nice! Badger Badger loves to read [send heart] [send heart] [send heart] I hope not to be knifed [almost crying] They are a life-and-death victory in the book, I hope there will be a good ending here [crying] Ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha I finally finished reading the main text and some of the extras in one go after saving for a long time! I really feel like it's one of the best HP fics I've ever seen! ! ! There is no OOC feeling! ! ! The plot is also very reasonable, and the emotional lines are also very touching [Sending Hearts] [Sending Hearts] [Sending Hearts] [Blowing Kisses] [Blowing Kisses] [Blowing Kisses]

It's really super pretty! ! At first I thought it was another cliche plot, but then I saw Ariana resurrected. Do you know how excited I was!

Wow, it's really well written! An idea I never thought of, Wenda Rozier is reborn in God's Movement! GGAD Wu Cui Party is ecstatic [sending hearts]

It's so good that I finished it in two days. It's not enough. It's a masterpiece! It's wonderful. It's the first time I've seen it unfold with the power of the saints. This book doesn't deliberately whitewash Slytherin. If there is a third choice, it doesn't have to be Death Eaters. They can take another path. At the same time, I have no prejudice against Gryffindor. In the past, I also thought that the lion was reckless and Albus was partial and exploitative because of some fan fiction. But this article made me truly feel the greatness of the White Wizard, and I finally understood why there are a thousand Hamlets for a thousand readers. I saw the "Hamlet" in the author's eyes. Forgive me for not knowing how to describe it in words. I am deeply attracted by him/them in your eyes.

I was so excited when I saw this article, because I like Wenda Rozier very much, GGAD, the author has a very good grasp of the relationship between Wenda and Grindelwald👍🏻, and it is also my ideal interpretation and fantasy of her, super awesome (๑ `▽´๑)۶! ! ! Come on! ! !

This is the first well-written book I have seen on Tomato. The nobility and elegance of the French Black Rose are vividly reflected. The extra story about GGVR in the previous life is GG's redemption of VR. As a person who is allergic to redemption, I was shocked! All in all, for the greater good!

Just ask for a good review. It's really well written. The best thing is that the flat characters are fleshed out, such as Pansy. Although some people will say that OOC has become more beautiful and smart, but a person's life is so long. When you encounter an opportunity, your thoughts will change and the whole person will become better. This kind of OOC is really good.

It's really good, I forgot to comment when I finished it. Being a saint is my husband's unfulfilled dream. White doves and ravens intertwine, and black roses slowly bloom. She established a firm foothold in the new era and once again wrote the glory that belongs to Wenda. Time spans, from the last century to the present, generations of heroes have written the glorious chapter of wizards. I am very grateful to be able to follow the author's writing and enter this wonderful fantasy world. Let us go to glory together. ——HL. TWL. Y. R.

A rare cp of the protagonist x Anna, the interaction between the protagonist and Anna is cute. But the first 130 chapters are not very good, and the interaction between the protagonist and Anna only accounts for about 10% of the space. About 60% of the text is an insufficiently brief summary and retelling of the original content, which is very watery. 20% Are original events that have been changed by the protagonist, and they are basically lackluster. But occasionally, the 10% ggad that mixes in the interaction between the protagonists to stir up trouble and the interaction between the ad protagonists are quite good. It wasn't until Harry was in sixth grade and the protagonist graduated, and the proportion of original plots increased, that things started to get better.

The writing is very good. Sister Wenda is so handsome. I have read Tomato for so long and this article is my favorite. Wenda Rozier, the French Black Rose, is proud, beautiful, powerful, and elegant. These are the most outstanding characteristics of Wenda in my opinion. The author shows them all perfectly, and the interaction with Anna is also super sweet.

The positive reviews were mainly given to Pansy's Awakening, which leads to it. The difference is that the author seems to have only read the fanfic and has not read the original work or the movie. There are many plot deviations. For example, it is Bill who is in Egypt instead of Charlie. Ron's family went to Egypt to visit the pyramids instead of seeing the dragons. The dementors' hands do not look like dead people. The classic plot Riddle takes Harry to see the memory is gone. The key plot is that Mr. Weasley warns Harry not to go find Sirius. In some places, it feels like I have read the original work... Maybe the author has forgotten some parts 😂

This subject really touches my heart. I just can't read it enough. Please give the author more updates. If you like it, I hope it won't collapse outside.

It's absolutely stunning, it's really beautiful [sending my heart][sending my heart][sending my heart][sending my heart] Come on, come on, this book is going to be a hit [Sending Hearts]

The writing style is super good, it can be written into a composition, the logic is online, Wenda's character is very full, but it is too short. 205 Is not enough to read,,,, in short, it is super good-looking! ! ! ! ! !

Very good, I really like the emotional descriptions of the four corners, whether it is the intertwined love and interest between Wenda and Arianna, or the relationship between Wenda and Gehuang, this feeling is so cool!

Five-star praise, completely in line with my idea of ​​Wenda! Smart, calm, beautiful, and resourceful, this article is highly recommended! (◦˙▽˙◦) The most beautiful HP fanfic in my opinion, bar none! ✧*. ٩(ˊωˋ*)و✧*.

The author is really great! It can be seen that the author paid great attention to the original work when writing the book and also referred to a lot of literature [Blowing Kiss]. In terms of restoring the details of the original text and designing the development of the new storyline, the conception is really clever! What is different from other HP fics is that in addition to writing the emotional line and making up for the regrets of the original work, the author of this book is also very detailed in the depiction of the protagonist's career line! The overall concept has also become more sublimated! The secrecy law was finally overturnedhhh After reading it, I'm still a little bit unsatisfied. What is particularly worth mentioning is the author's rewriting and shaping of the character Pansy. There is so little fun with Pansy in the HP novel! ! ! Really, this book is definitely of the highest quality among HB fanfics! Thank you to the author for sending love [send heart][send heart][send heart][send heart][send heart]

Hey hey hey here~ A book with a super new theme, the French Black Rose is so handsome that everyone is so handsome, the GGAD blood alliance is rebuilt... It's a love letter from a dream! ! ! But can you please add more? It's very painful to wait for updates every day...[Cry][cry][cry]

Zundi looks good! I really love this setting! The plot of Wenda and GGAD is also interesting

I have to say it's really beautiful! I clicked on this article by accident and finished reading it in a moved way. At first, I thought this was just a simple HP fanfic, a pastime when I was bored, but I was gradually moved by this article. My love and I both fell into the high tower, and you and your heart are both hidden in the midsummer. I wish GGAD and Raven White Dove safety, success and happiness! [Blowing kiss]

I'm absolutely blown away. My wife's writing is so good. For example, the characters are very delicate, the story logic is also very compact, and there are also some small extras, and the ideological logic is simply amazing [Admiration] Who knows? After reading this article, I felt that the others were a bit like children's play house.

It's really beautiful! ! ! It's so beautiful that I can't describe it in words! ! ! Recommend! ! !

It's beautiful. Very few hp fanfics are written from this perspective. The writing style is also very good. The black raven is really handsome to me. All in all, it's super beautiful.

Well, how should I put it, it is the first Lily book I have read. Well, it's probably the last one I read. To be honest, if it weren't for the lack of interest in reading Harry Potter, I might not be suitable for reading this kind of book.

Super pretty! It's very comfortable to read [please ask for updates] The writing is very good and the logic is clear