Miracles do exist.
Don't be afraid, don't cry.
Diseases and injuries do not exist, and even the lost limbs are revived. This is the paradise of miracles - Jordan Town.
Detective Dacheng, who entered Jordan Town to investigate because he was worried about his assistant who had not yet returned, encountered suspicious deaths one after another. For people who believe in miracles, can a famous detective armed with logic defeat the collective delusions of fanatical believers?
Reader comments
Shirai, the god of setting! I have been exposed to many setting-based scripts before, and their settings are basically set up to limit a few solutions. However, Shirai truly integrated the settings into the story and reasoning, allowing his pseudo-solutions and true solution reasoning to be smooth.
Xinbenge has been criticized before for being more about tricks than motives, and many outrageous motives have appeared, but I think the motives of this "Detective's Sacrifice" are more exciting than its tricks, and it is very amazing.
In addition, if there are reasoning fans who feel that the logical reasoning in this article is not satisfactory enough, don't be disappointed with Shirai. I highly recommend his "Elephant Head". The logic is interlocking, the tricks are very exciting, and it is very beautiful.
Invincible, worthy of being a five-time winner. There is a slow start at the beginning, but it all sets the stage for the entire work. After the incident, two false solutions and one true solution were carried out. There is a twist at the end, explaining the motivation behind the truth. Then let's get to the topic: The Detective's Sacrifice. Everything is to make her become a famous detective. It's a really awesome work. The slow heat in the front made me want to spray, but the back is really invincible.
In addition to the reasoning part of this book, the most important thing is that it made me understand how cults control people. When I first read the first scene, I found it unbelievable, but then I gradually became convinced. It was really chilling.
I actually guessed the title of this book many times while I was reading it. I thought it might be a famous detective who sacrificed his own death to get the truth. I didn't expect that it turned out to be that way when I read the end. In fact, Shirai is really good at coming up with titles. I remember one of his short stories, Nanako, in which a man died. It was only after reading the short story that I finally realized the true meaning of the title and the first case. After reading the end and thinking about the title, I got goosebumps and a feeling of enlightenment. I don't know how to put it. In fact, I didn't get much of Dacheng's motivation in the end, but the suspense reasoning and reversal of this book are very good. Overall, it is an excellent mystery novel.
It's okay, it's Shirai's first work [you taste it carefully]
It's quite good-looking, but a bit ugly, but it's also quite good-looking. I thought it was a bit ugly when I looked at it, but after watching it I thought it was quite good-looking.
For Miss Rinlinko
I was really shocked when I saw this [crying] The reversals come one after another.
Except for the third answer where the right finger was broken and the line was not bent in advance (I personally feel that it cannot be pushed out if you cannot press the knob), the reasoning is generally rigorous. You may think that some of the methods are a bit far-fetched, but I watched Xinbenge just to see this kind of novel reasoning. In addition, the multiple answers in this work are not written just for the sake of writing. It can even be said that the multiple answers themselves are the core trick. This is what stood out to me the most.
It took me an entire afternoon to read it, so awesome! Did I see my assistant's reasoning halfway through? ? Finally it was explained. The last two answers are also very interesting, and the overall reading will not feel boring. The final motivation is both dramatic and reasonable, which fits the title of the book and is impressive. Compared with Shirai's other works, it is too normal, not heavy-handed, and suitable for anyone to fall into.
You really have to read to the end to know the meaning of the title. The author's writing style is still very delicate. There are a lot of foreshadowings and call backs throughout the book. The style is also unconventional. You didn't expect this person to die but he died suddenly. The highlight of the whole story is not the case itself, but the reversal of the narrative. Whether you can accept the final motive is a matter of opinion. It is a mystery novel with a unique style and can be rated 4.5.
Can anyone help me explain why w can devise such a trick without being affected by complete hallucinations, such as using Franklin's belief that he has legs to transport the corpse. According to the motive, w is a fanatical believer of Jim. He should also think that Franklin has legs like many believers. Although it is not stated clearly in the article, isn't this the same as believers seeing w as a normal adult? Does this mean that w is just the actual executor of the trick? The designer of this trick is still Jim.
In the end, it turned out to be a response to the beginning. I didn't expect it to appear twice. Although there are a few bugs and the final reveal part is written in a roundabout way, it is still a very good book. For Linlinzi
Climaxes and twists and turns, a rare masterpiece
The plot of this book is so exciting! Detective Otsuka's experience in Jordan Town reminded me of a friend of mine who was also in trouble. There is a sentence in the book that impressed me deeply: "Don't be afraid, don't cry." This is not only an encouragement to the characters in the book, but also an inspiration to our lives. In the face of difficulties, we cannot give up easily and must be brave to find answers. I recommend everyone to read this book "The Sacrifice of a Detective".
When I first read this title, I thought that the detective sacrificed herself to solve the case, but I didn't expect that the people were sacrificed in order for her to become a famous detective. I thought the first story was just a short story that led to the detective, but I didn't expect that the case was the trigger that led to the entire tragedy. There are twists and turns one after another. Although the reasoning part is a bit weak, overall it is an unexpected ending.
4 Stars are for the final group suicide reversal.
This book is highly recommended, so I came here to read it. It didn't make me feel amazing. First of all, the fake answer is really nonsense. It may be that the meaning is clearly given to the readers and it is fake. The real answer later was actually a trick on the leader's vision problem, which I ruled out at first after the semi-blind person pointed it out. The motive is the most interesting. In terms of the execution of the murder, I actually prefer three cases. It is more rigorous to use the joint killing of three believers. According to the last answer, the first agent, you were attacked and injured by a child. Your first reaction was to scream and escape to your room, instead of knocking on the door to call for help on the same floor. Moreover, the agents did not inflict any counter-attack damage on the attackers. Is this agent here to be funny?
Lin Linzi knows the murderer, but she still thinks that she can kill the murderer with a steel ring, ah? So brave? The characters are so smart, and the lunch boxes at the end are so dreamy.
Q's awakening is also amazing.
The 4 stars are just for Rin Linzi's sacrifice, which is really stupid.
The last time I saw a rigorous closed-loop logic was "Fictional Reasoning". Sure enough, it's too difficult to be a fan.
This suspenseful mystery novel is based on a real case, with interlocking plots and detailed descriptions that are so precise that it makes your back shiver, as if you can touch the temperature and atmosphere of the crime scene. The author cleverly interweaves the complexity of human nature with the weirdness of crimes. Every reversal is like peeling an onion, making people want to stop. It is one of the most immersive mystery works I have read recently.
One of my favorite books. The paradox reasoning is really exciting. At the end, the male protagonist's motive for crazy comments was revealed and he became a god. I loved Shirai's work.
It's so exciting, and it's worthy of Tomoyuki Shirai. I had often heard of him before, but had never read his works. I was quite shocked when I read his "Nobody Died" for the first time some time ago. And when I opened this more famous "The Sacrifice of a Detective", at first I wondered if it could really surpass the previous one? The result is yes. Whether it is the three sets of reasoning in the middle or the truth about the sacrifice of more than 900 people in Dacheng at the end, it is very exciting. And it's inexplicably touching [crying]
This is the first time I read the setting-based reasoning. It may be a little boring at first, but it becomes more and more exciting later on. For this book, the setting is equivalent to the existence itself, which is reflected all the time.
In addition, the triple solution is also very interesting.
The flashback + grand narrative won my heart. The logic is generally closed and perfect. It is a very orthodox logical reasoning. Excellent work.
Great logic flow🙏🙏🙏
Everything is for Lin Linzi
It has to be Shirai. I think this should be his most serious character.
A five-star masterpiece with four reversals, no explanation! I have read more than ten Japanese mystery books recently, and apart from Seiichiro Oyama, this is the one that satisfies me the most. As for the events inside, they are adapted from real events. Those who are interested can learn about the Jonestown Massacre.
Shirai's work is a super immersive crime-solving journey. Be careful with small people [laughing evilly].
The multiple reversals and final choices are awesome. It is relatively slow in the early stage but many small details may become foreshadowing in the later stage. In the end, reasoning, human nature, religion and other aspects are intertwined. Although some details of the reasoning are open to discussion, and some areas do not stand up to careful scrutiny, the overall flaws are not hidden, and it is still worth watching.
The plot description and reversal are very good, but the reasoning part is a bit flawed. Overall, it is a masterpiece that does not hide its flaws.
Like The Elephant's Head, they are both god-level works. Shirai is really a genius in writing novels.
I suggest you watch it, I won't say much.
Um. . . I have never read this new type of mystery novel before. I like old-fashioned mystery novels [face covering]. The murderer's motive in the end is surprising
Shirai, the god of setting! I have been exposed to many setting-based scripts before, and their settings are basically set up to limit a few solutions. However, Shirai truly integrated the settings into the story and reasoning, allowing his pseudo-solutions and true solution reasoning to be smooth. Xinbenge has been criticized before for being more about tricks than motives, and many outrageous motives have appeared, but I think the motives of this "Detective's Sacrifice" are more exciting than its tricks, and it is very amazing. In addition, if there are reasoning fans who feel that the logical reasoning in this article is not satisfactory enough, don't be disappointed with Shirai. I highly recommend his "Elephant Head". The logic is interlocking, the tricks are very exciting, and it is very beautiful.
Invincible, worthy of being a five-time winner. There is a slow start at the beginning, but it all sets the stage for the entire work. After the incident, two false solutions and one true solution were carried out. There is a twist at the end, explaining the motivation behind the truth. Then let's get to the topic: The Detective's Sacrifice. Everything is to make her become a famous detective. It's a really awesome work. The slow heat in the front made me want to spray, but the back is really invincible.
In addition to the reasoning part of this book, the most important thing is that it made me understand how cults control people. When I first read the first scene, I found it unbelievable, but then I gradually became convinced. It was really chilling.
I actually guessed the title of this book many times while I was reading it. I thought it might be a famous detective who sacrificed his own death to get the truth. I didn't expect that it turned out to be that way when I read the end. In fact, Shirai is really good at coming up with titles. I remember one of his short stories, Nanako, in which a man died. It was only after reading the short story that I finally realized the true meaning of the title and the first case. After reading the end and thinking about the title, I got goosebumps and a feeling of enlightenment. I don't know how to put it. In fact, I didn't get much of Dacheng's motivation in the end, but the suspense reasoning and reversal of this book are very good. Overall, it is an excellent mystery novel.
It's okay, it's Shirai's first work [you taste it carefully]
It's quite good-looking, but a bit ugly, but it's also quite good-looking. I thought it was a bit ugly when I looked at it, but after watching it I thought it was quite good-looking.
For Miss Rinlinko I was really shocked when I saw this [crying] The reversals come one after another.
Except for the third answer where the right finger was broken and the line was not bent in advance (I personally feel that it cannot be pushed out if you cannot press the knob), the reasoning is generally rigorous. You may think that some of the methods are a bit far-fetched, but I watched Xinbenge just to see this kind of novel reasoning. In addition, the multiple answers in this work are not written just for the sake of writing. It can even be said that the multiple answers themselves are the core trick. This is what stood out to me the most.
It took me an entire afternoon to read it, so awesome! Did I see my assistant's reasoning halfway through? ? Finally it was explained. The last two answers are also very interesting, and the overall reading will not feel boring. The final motivation is both dramatic and reasonable, which fits the title of the book and is impressive. Compared with Shirai's other works, it is too normal, not heavy-handed, and suitable for anyone to fall into.
You really have to read to the end to know the meaning of the title. The author's writing style is still very delicate. There are a lot of foreshadowings and call backs throughout the book. The style is also unconventional. You didn't expect this person to die but he died suddenly. The highlight of the whole story is not the case itself, but the reversal of the narrative. Whether you can accept the final motive is a matter of opinion. It is a mystery novel with a unique style and can be rated 4.5.
Can anyone help me explain why w can devise such a trick without being affected by complete hallucinations, such as using Franklin's belief that he has legs to transport the corpse. According to the motive, w is a fanatical believer of Jim. He should also think that Franklin has legs like many believers. Although it is not stated clearly in the article, isn't this the same as believers seeing w as a normal adult? Does this mean that w is just the actual executor of the trick? The designer of this trick is still Jim.
In the end, it turned out to be a response to the beginning. I didn't expect it to appear twice. Although there are a few bugs and the final reveal part is written in a roundabout way, it is still a very good book. For Linlinzi
Climaxes and twists and turns, a rare masterpiece
The plot of this book is so exciting! Detective Otsuka's experience in Jordan Town reminded me of a friend of mine who was also in trouble. There is a sentence in the book that impressed me deeply: "Don't be afraid, don't cry." This is not only an encouragement to the characters in the book, but also an inspiration to our lives. In the face of difficulties, we cannot give up easily and must be brave to find answers. I recommend everyone to read this book "The Sacrifice of a Detective".
When I first read this title, I thought that the detective sacrificed herself to solve the case, but I didn't expect that the people were sacrificed in order for her to become a famous detective. I thought the first story was just a short story that led to the detective, but I didn't expect that the case was the trigger that led to the entire tragedy. There are twists and turns one after another. Although the reasoning part is a bit weak, overall it is an unexpected ending.
4 Stars are for the final group suicide reversal. This book is highly recommended, so I came here to read it. It didn't make me feel amazing. First of all, the fake answer is really nonsense. It may be that the meaning is clearly given to the readers and it is fake. The real answer later was actually a trick on the leader's vision problem, which I ruled out at first after the semi-blind person pointed it out. The motive is the most interesting. In terms of the execution of the murder, I actually prefer three cases. It is more rigorous to use the joint killing of three believers. According to the last answer, the first agent, you were attacked and injured by a child. Your first reaction was to scream and escape to your room, instead of knocking on the door to call for help on the same floor. Moreover, the agents did not inflict any counter-attack damage on the attackers. Is this agent here to be funny? Lin Linzi knows the murderer, but she still thinks that she can kill the murderer with a steel ring, ah? So brave? The characters are so smart, and the lunch boxes at the end are so dreamy. Q's awakening is also amazing. The 4 stars are just for Rin Linzi's sacrifice, which is really stupid. The last time I saw a rigorous closed-loop logic was "Fictional Reasoning". Sure enough, it's too difficult to be a fan.
This suspenseful mystery novel is based on a real case, with interlocking plots and detailed descriptions that are so precise that it makes your back shiver, as if you can touch the temperature and atmosphere of the crime scene. The author cleverly interweaves the complexity of human nature with the weirdness of crimes. Every reversal is like peeling an onion, making people want to stop. It is one of the most immersive mystery works I have read recently.
One of my favorite books. The paradox reasoning is really exciting. At the end, the male protagonist's motive for crazy comments was revealed and he became a god. I loved Shirai's work.
It's so exciting, and it's worthy of Tomoyuki Shirai. I had often heard of him before, but had never read his works. I was quite shocked when I read his "Nobody Died" for the first time some time ago. And when I opened this more famous "The Sacrifice of a Detective", at first I wondered if it could really surpass the previous one? The result is yes. Whether it is the three sets of reasoning in the middle or the truth about the sacrifice of more than 900 people in Dacheng at the end, it is very exciting. And it's inexplicably touching [crying]
This is the first time I read the setting-based reasoning. It may be a little boring at first, but it becomes more and more exciting later on. For this book, the setting is equivalent to the existence itself, which is reflected all the time. In addition, the triple solution is also very interesting. The flashback + grand narrative won my heart. The logic is generally closed and perfect. It is a very orthodox logical reasoning. Excellent work.
Great logic flow🙏🙏🙏
Everything is for Lin Linzi
It has to be Shirai. I think this should be his most serious character.
A five-star masterpiece with four reversals, no explanation! I have read more than ten Japanese mystery books recently, and apart from Seiichiro Oyama, this is the one that satisfies me the most. As for the events inside, they are adapted from real events. Those who are interested can learn about the Jonestown Massacre.
Shirai's work is a super immersive crime-solving journey. Be careful with small people [laughing evilly].
The multiple reversals and final choices are awesome. It is relatively slow in the early stage but many small details may become foreshadowing in the later stage. In the end, reasoning, human nature, religion and other aspects are intertwined. Although some details of the reasoning are open to discussion, and some areas do not stand up to careful scrutiny, the overall flaws are not hidden, and it is still worth watching.
The plot description and reversal are very good, but the reasoning part is a bit flawed. Overall, it is a masterpiece that does not hide its flaws.
Like The Elephant's Head, they are both god-level works. Shirai is really a genius in writing novels.
I suggest you watch it, I won't say much.
Um. . . I have never read this new type of mystery novel before. I like old-fashioned mystery novels [face covering]. The murderer's motive in the end is surprising