**

How much skill does the author have? After reading dozens of chapters, I became mentally disturbed, depressed and uncomfortable, just like depression. It succeeded in creating a plot that was reasonable from everyone's point of view, but it was just too sadistic. Maybe what I brought in was Bai (Ning) Yuechen's perspective. Especially when Ning had a crush on someone, and when he saw a comment saying that this person was the heroine of another book by the author, he felt very sad and his heart was broken. This is destined to be fruitless. I must catch her and torture her. I haven't watched the rest of the plot, but I feel that Ning's life was completely ruined by the Bai family. I have to wait a few days to read this book.

I have listened to many books on Tomato, and this is the first time I like all the works of an author so much! From now on, whenever a new book comes out, I won't brag about it. [Love][Love][Love][Love]

I like this kind of plot setting very much, and I look forward to what the author will write in the future [sending my heart][sending my heart][sending my heart]

After reading it for a day and a half, I finally finished it. As a boy (I don't know if it is normal for boys to love this kind of thing), I read this book with empathy for the first time. To be honest, it is very well written. It is also very emotional. Overall, it looks good. I originally wanted to write it in the morning, but I saw the connection in the book and read the author's other novels. It was only now that I thought of writing a book review. As a novel written in 24 years, it is a pity that I only read it now. It is also a pity that I did not experience the joy of catching up (but it is not a big problem). I like Ning very much. Bai Ye is okay, of course Xiao Chuyi likes her better, and also sympathizes with Aunt Shi and Shen Zhinian's experiences, and Bai's father is really not a thing. I really like the author's narrative style and writing style. I had a lot to say before I started writing. I didn't know what to write when I was writing. It's quite emotional, although it's a bit sadistic, but luckily it's He🥹. I'm looking forward to the author starting a new book. I haven't finished reading other works yet, but it's only in the past two days. Hehe, that's it (poor expression😭). I hope the author will write better and better. Come on🥰🥰🥰

I think this book is really good, but I also have a lot of regrets. (Personally, I feel a lot of regrets) At the front, the writing is not particularly good, but the content is really great. Generally speaking, Bai has Bai's difficulties, and Ning has Ning's difficulties. Some words that may sound like tea to us are actually not. There is a reason why Bai said the embarrassing words. Anyway, both heroines are very good. However, I think this story is better than Be's. The writing style is quite good. It makes me feel that the author is very rich and the knowledge involved is also very professional.

Bai Yi written by the author is very similar to me in many parts. My mother was also full of prejudice against me. When I was a child, I was often kicked out of the house to reflect, but I usually sneaked back after half a day. Family love is a very luxurious thing for me. My mother can be full of kindness and enthusiasm towards strangers, but she will not greet me with a smile. Most of the time, she only has indifference and disgust. When I watch Bai Yi, I will unconsciously get involved, and I will always feel angry and sad unconsciously. Only then do I realize that I am still the child I was back then, and I have never really come out. In this work, everyone is more or less reasonable, and also has human flaws and dark sides, no matter Xiaobai, Shi Yu or Xiao Ning. Xiao Ning learned to be cold and mean, and gradually became Bai Yi. Bai Yi learned to take revenge and use family affection, and gradually became Shi Yu, and Shi Yu would even take revenge on his own daughter. He would do whatever it takes to get revenge, so why not be like Lao Bai? In fact, the author's most saddening passage is the one where Shi Yu shows her maternal nature when Xiao Ning is taken back. My mother would care about her colleagues' children and my neighbor's sister like a mother, but she never cared about me, and because she hated my father, she always scolded me. Why do I look so like him? I couldn't help but burst into tears while watching it. It was so similar, and I couldn't help but feel that the author wrote it really well. In fact, after reading it now, I really feel that what the author wrote is true and cruel. Everyone is contradictory. Maybe we will not be able to meet our he in the end, but most of the time we have tried our best to live, so why bother to care about the final result. I hope the author can give each character an ending, and I hope the work can have a good ending, not necessarily hex, but full, coherent, and reasonable. I probably won't have much time to read novels in the future, the paper is killing me! Save the child~ I have to clean up myself and move forward. I hope that when I open the app again, I can see the perfect ending of the work. I also thank the author for allowing me to see such excellent works. I wish the author all his works to be popular, success in work, and a happy life!

This is a good heroine who is crazy enough, but there is no absolute good person in the whole story, and she all has her own difficulties. However, it is also these characters who have extreme abstract ideas. Father Bai is a typical domineering man who forced her to love him, which led to Shi's indifference to the children, which must have also led to Ning's mother's death. But it doesn't matter to him, even if there is no love, there are people, but the mistakes of the previous generation should not be retaliated on the next generation. All kinds of problems caused Bai's ideological problems. The arrival of Ning and Shi's prejudice have greatly aggravated it. Is Shi wrong? She is, but is it all her fault? No, Bai's father is the source of everything. I hope there will be no good results, and I hope Bai Ning can have a normal relationship. From what I have read so far, I personally think this book is quite good. I hope the author can give Ning Bai a good ending. Ah, I saw it was over. The final plot was Ning's last resistance. In her opinion, apart from Bai Yueguang, whom she could never get, there was only Bai left in the world. So that's how it ended! But the author must let their children grow up well.

The writing is good, very similar to the two books with Cheng Zi's Eyes, but I always feel that the heroine is so kind. Excessive kindness is cowardice. I really can't stand against this couple. I would rather hope that the heroine is redeemed by Xia Nuannuan in the end, and then they get together. I don't know how the author will write that the heroine will be with this madman in the end. It's rated four stars. It's completely due to the struggle between the mother and daughter of the Bai family that affects the protagonist. There's also one unrealistic aspect. The protagonist has been imprisoned for two full months and still has the strength to cry and beg for mercy. A normal person would have been turned into a charlatan under the dual mental and physical torture. It's The Walking Dead, and I've been treated like this for two months. It's really uncomfortable to watch the main character cry all the time and be scared to the point of pissing. Although I know the main character is a female, and she is pampered and not as tough as a male, but you can't be more stubborn. There is no point in being submissive!

To be honest, the author's writing is really beautiful. Come on Not bad, not bad, ha [blowing kiss][blowing kiss][blowing kiss]

It looks good. Although I understand it, I really feel that Bai Yi is aggrieved. If I had killed Yuochen earlier, I might have done so in front of Shigure. I really can't see why I'm tempted at the moment. (Didn't watch the previous one) [cover face][cover face] The first part is good, but the second part is just for emotional reasons. In fact, I have actually thought about this kind of plot before. I think that either the evil will be in vain, everything will be destroyed, kill those who should be killed, destroy everything, and directly become a villain, or I will rise up and take revenge, yes, it will be a river of blood [laughing and crying] [laughing and crying] [laughing and crying]

After reading it, the plot is really exciting and the writing is really excellent. I feel like I have seen Yang Xiaoxing. No matter who it is, except for the father, they are all pitiful people. They transfer hatred to each other and cannot understand each other to hurt each other. It makes people unable to hate or love. I'm really looking forward to the crematorium plot behind the heroine, but I hope I can't catch it. Let's arrange a new heroine. From a third-party perspective, Bai Yue is the one who suffers the most pain. The heroine dislikes everything because of her hatred. She abused Bai Yue since she was a child. I really can't think of any reason why Bai Yue would forgive him later and become a CP.

Xu Lun District is very exciting, a large-scale debate competition, a large-scale splitting scene around Bai's father, Shi's mother, Bai and Shi's mother's lover's daughter, the ending must be h, the plot is okay, the characters behave reasonably, people with good views are not recommended to watch

It's sad and sweet. If you like the more special type, you can check it out.

It was a very novel experience to read it in one night. It is not the beauty of fairy tales, but only the cruelty and helplessness of reality. The two female protagonists are very miserable and have tortured each other for life due to family reasons. The whole book is very sad except for Xia Wen. After reading it, I still feel a little uncomfortable. Maybe it is because I haven't read enough. I have never read such a book, but the author still writes very well and portrays each character in a three-dimensional way, unlike the formulaic heroines of many books. I also wish everyone can meet someone who treats you well, be safe and happy (this is the first time I write such a long book review, the expression may be incorrect, please forgive me)

It's very well written. I really can't change it to CP. I feel so sad when I read it [crying][crying][crying]

In fact, I have long planned to give a book review when it is finished. Wonderful This is my first review of this novel. Not only is the plot wonderful, but the characterization is also wonderful. The improvement of the author's writing style is also becoming more and more obvious. In fact, I have been exposed to the author's previous works before, but I don't know why there are always some reasons to persuade me to quit. Maybe some of the plots are too bloody, but in short, I feel relatively bland. After watching half of it, I lost my impression after a few months. The characters in the article are all very flesh and blood, and everyone even has their own difficulties and inner pursuits, which makes the plot interesting. Shi Yu's partiality is closely related to the extremely tragic experience behind her, and Bai Yi's coldness and strength are inseparable from her being indifferent and neglected since she was a child. Not to mention Ning, who went from an innocent little white flower to a self-reliant black lotus, and Bai's father... Uh... Beast. In fact, many readers like to bring in Ning's perspective at the beginning, but if they are brought in from the perspective of different characters, they seem to have different feelings. In fact, from the beginning to the middle of the plot, Ning was a victim, but in the later stages, there was no distinction between right and wrong (although Bai's three views are a bit hard to describe... 1), But the characterization of the characters and the ups and downs, and the interlocking plots deeply moved me. My favorite part is the scene where Bai and Ning quarrel. This aspect is also quite interesting. Ning's eloquence is really good. Every time I see Ning cursing, I always feel crazy and superior (I have to praise the author for this). Bai was always in a weak position at the beginning, but then he gradually became stronger. Later, he made Ning faint. I really didn't expect that 23333 In addition, Liu Yingzhen's description is also very interesting. As Bai's best friend, he can always promote the development of the storyline just right, and he can really make different evaluations from different angles. A best friend who is truly there for you, a spy (bushi) who likes to instigate the two of you, or even a clear, objective and rational bystander. All in all, this book is really interesting in every way. It doesn't matter what your perspective is, because some of the plots in it are really outrageous and really exciting. I highly recommend them. They are among the top ones among all the Lily novels I have read.

It's a nice setting with two female protagonists, mainly because it's not childish. It's said to be a sadistic story, but the sadism is within the acceptable range. Bonus points. I always thought that the one being abused was the little white-flowered heroine, but I found out later that it was Bai Yi who was being abused. Don't be too outrageous [face covering]. The overall score should be around 9.2, And the audience for sadistic stories is still small.

It's beautiful, I love watching it, I watch it lying down, sitting, shitting, watching it while sleeping, watching it like crazy, I want to watch it all the time, I watch it all [Adoration] [Adoration] [Adoration] It's just too little [I'm about to cry] [I'm about to cry]

I don't know why, but I feel that this kind of subject matter and this kind of relationship are constantly being edited and messed up, and it's quite sad now. If I really do something in the future, even if I chase my wife in the crematorium, I still feel like [blowing kiss] [blowing kiss] [blowing kiss] Of course, my wife wrote it very well, come on, look forward to it [sending my heart]

I have been reading this book for so long, and I have found that in the whole book, there is only one person who is the clowniest, me. Well, how should I put it? To be honest, the plot of this book is okay, slightly poisonous, maybe 40% poisonous. The only drawback is that some of the twists and turns in the plot are a bit baffling, and maybe it's a matter of my personal sense of hearing. I feel like some of the lines are a bit awkward. The characters are well drawn, and never fail from beginning to end. People who should be vicious will always be vicious, and kind people will always be kind. Except for Father Bai, who is all at fault, everyone else is more or less pitiful. In the early stage, 30% of the 40% reading is there, so if you can handle it, this book is still worth reading. If you haven't read the background story, I am basically about 70% sure that you can finish it, okay. I read the author's next book.

Crazy reminder for updates. So far, the characters have their own behavioral logic. It hurts my stomach, but it is well written. The follow-up is probably that the imprisonment of the protagonist caused Shi Yu's death. At this time, Bai Yi discovered his differences with the protagonist and the protagonist's love for Xia, and imprisoned the protagonist. (Here begins the irresponsible guessing.) Let's speculate based on the plot of another book. Let's talk about the conclusion first. Brother Bai was the mastermind behind the murder of Bai Yi and put the blame on the protagonist. In the end, it was revealed that he escaped abroad and was solved by Bai Yi in a car accident. Bai Jinmo was deliberately approached by Brother Bai to get close to the protagonist. Brother Bai usually pretends to be kind, but is not as good as Bai Yi, so he plans to engage in intrigues. In essence, he is still inheriting the cold-blooded calculations of the Bai family. Bai Yi's hatred is on the surface, but Brother Bai hates his mother and the protagonist in his heart. He uses the protagonist as a raft and plans to kill Bai Yi to get the family property. The family was ruined, and Bai's father finally got his comeuppance. The two children were so much like him, I hope he would be so happy that he would cry. Let's make another guess. If Shi Yu's death was caused by Brother Bai and not Bai Yi, then it is probably still possible that he would not be killed in the end. Finally, I hope the author will add more updates, it is completely insufficient.

Everyone's position in this novel is different. There is no absolute right or wrong. The influence of family environment makes it... Quite difficult to review. As expected, Shuangwen is still suitable for me, but this book is also quite good. The writing style, character setting, etc. Are all very good. It is still worth reading.

It must be 5 stars. I have devoted myself to this book since the summer vacation. I have been chasing it for a day. I have experienced so much sadness with them. I can still remember it vividly [crying]. Sometimes I couldn't sleep at three o'clock in the morning. Seeing the happiness of the two of them is actually very good. I can always see Bai Ning and Bai Ning tearing up each other, but I always think that neither of them is wrong (but I do not deny the wrong things they have done). Both of them are from the previous generation. Victim of grudges, and you Bai Jingyuan, you really deserve to die [smile] Each character has a distinct personality, and the character's personality is always changing. Although it is really sad to see them being abused, when they see them happy, they feel better. Rather than living with hatred for a lifetime, it is better to let go of the grudge and hope that the two of them will have a better future. I also hope that the next book Jiang and Gu will have desserts (although it may also be abusive)

After reading so many double-heroine novels, Bai Yi's image is the most deeply rooted in my heart. Although I prefer the author's other book Wen Xia, Bai Yi's portrayal is so good that it makes me tremble. Just by comparison, Bai Yi is Lily's most ruthless heroine. It's really a success [Blow kiss]

It was pretty good. It was too depressing while I was reading it. I abandoned the book several times. But along the way, I was introduced to both Bai's perspective and Ning's perspective. It really gave me a heart attack [laughs]. The final ending was not forcefully satisfying, but more realistic. It can only be said that letting Bai Ning continue to be entangled like this is not another "be/he" ending? [Face covering] [Thinking] (Bai Yichu is an angel [blowing kiss]) If you like torture, you can read it. The author's writing style is very good, and the character creation has always had a stable core (if you want to know more about the characters, you can read the previous readers who posted long comments). After seeing the emotional line between the protagonists in the end, I can only say that I am relieved. It's just that the plot is a little bit goofy, the main text is basically not sweet, and some plots will make a person angry to death, so if you don't mind, don't get into it, there's no need to suffer. I quite like this book (personal preference). It's not easy for the author to write, so the score is a bit low, so I give it a good review.

It's exactly my type. It looks real and fake but doesn't seem like it. I'm really looking forward to the future development. I'll update it soon.

It's okay. The author's writing is really good, and he handles the character's personality very well. There's not much to say in terms of plot advancement. Even if it ends up being a BE, I think I can accept it. After all, I've read most of Tomato's sadistic articles and Dragon Clan. These are nothing to me. Come on and update.

8.7 Points? The human nature is well written, dark style. Although there are more thunderous relationships in reality than this, I really feel a sense of powerlessness that I can't beat the people in the novel. What about stacking buffs? It's full of twists and turns, a bit thunderous. (ー_ー)!!

How to put it, this is not a real world after all. But novels are inherently fictional, allowing people to escape from the real world. Regarding the characterization, Bai Yi actually wrote it very well, calm but longing for love. Although Bai Yi is seen as cold and ruthless in the whole story, it can be seen from the details that she longs for someone to love her and wants a home of her own. Ning Yuochen feels too persistent, and as a reader, I may not be able to appreciate her pain, so subjectively, I am actually biased towards Bai Yi, and I can sympathize with her very much. The plot of physical and psychological abuse is also very good, and the changes in the two people's mentality are also very complete and will not make people feel incomplete. Overall, it's a very good book, but the two of them are so good at arguing that after reading it, I wanted to fight someone else for 300 rounds.

It's good-looking, and the characters are well created. Bai is really unique among the novel characters I've come across. Ning's stubbornness and unyieldingness, and how he's forced to bow his head are also very good. The emotional development of Xiao Chuyi and Zhixia is beyond imagination. There is enough time, and each character has his or her own soul. The female characters such as Bai Yi, Ning Yuochen, Xia Wenwen, and Aunt Shi are very distinct. This book is really ranked in the top three among all the novels I read on Tomato. I hope the author will work hard ^0^~