**

This is the first Japanese novel I have read, and it is also the first novel I have read completely. I watched the animation first and then the novel. The animation was okay, and the novel is better, more complete, clearer, and has a better rhythm. I highly recommend anime fans to read the original novel.

It is a wonderful mystery novel. In fact, I have been thinking about the meaning of the title "Stand-in" before reading it. Now I feel that many things are actually stand-ins. Mizaki Ming is the stand-in for Wu Guo's daughter, Jiuguanniao Xiaorei is the stand-in for Reiko's aunt, Reiko's aunt is the stand-in for her mother, and Naru and Tsuneichi are stand-ins for non-existent people... Stand-ins are the expression of human nature, containing the connotation between good and evil. Flowers have two sides, human nature is between Buddha and demon. Everyone has a distinct personality, some are motivated by their own selfish interests, while others rise to the occasion and are not afraid of challenges. This group of fifteen-year-old boys used their courage to write an extraordinary chapter of youth.

I have watched anime before and was deeply impressed by the throat-piercing umbrella.

It has richer content than anime and is not as confusing as when watching anime.

It's a very good book, I think it's much better than the original one... The special identity of the deceased always reminds me of the marsh man... Aunt Reiko, who forgot the fact of her own death and didn't know that she was the deceased, must have been confused and desperate when she died for the second time. .

I give it five stars to Ayatsuji Yukito. The plot is a bit slow [laughing]. Personally, I prefer his mystery novels. This book has a strong two-dimensional flavor. I can imagine the animation scenes while reading it. After reading it, I can understand why it was animated in movies and TV shows [laughing]. It tastes right!

The plot of this book is so fascinating! The character of Mizaki Naru left a deep impression on me, and her words "Don't just take the surface at face value" are simply wise words. I especially hate that person who keeps spreading rumors, it's really annoying. But overall, this is a wonderful novel and worth reading!

I watched a TV series a few years ago, and I was super surprised to find this book in Tomato. I couldn't stop reading it. The descriptions are very detailed, and there are not as many dramatic conflicts as in the TV series, but it is more reasonable. Very exciting!

I watched anime about ten years ago. It was my first favorite Japanese manga. It completely captured my curiosity and was very exciting. I have not finished the original work until today. I have to say that the original work is more detailed (and more verbose...), But it lacks some visual impact compared to the anime, and the plot does not have the internal fighting at the end of the anime (this is not as exciting as the anime, and the final climax is not as violent as the anime). If you have never watched the anime, the mystery and suspense design of this novel is excellent, and the setting is also very interesting. Even if I already know the answer to the mystery, I can't help but marvel at the rich details that the author has laid out. Whenever the author reveals the secret, you will find that many details have been hinted at before. Although there is no reasoning element at all, the author has buried many clues from beginning to end, allowing readers to have a speculative interactive experience similar to the original plot. There are also some narrative tricks involved, but after all, I know the answer to the mystery, so I don't feel anything about it. People who don't know may be quite shocked.

A very exciting mystery or horror novel. If you like the atmosphere of horror stories, you must not miss it. The weird and terrifying atmosphere of the whole book is well rendered. There are many suspenses and foreshadowings in the early stage. These suspenses make people eager to see the truth. I almost read the book in one breath. In the later stage, I filled in the holes one by one and connected them one by one. After learning the truth, I suddenly realized that it had been hinted at earlier. It feels like part of the setting is like "Welcome to Derry", probably inspired by a little Stephen King. The combination of Stephen King-style horror and traditional Japanese supernatural horror makes this book more fascinating. Highly recommended!

It begins with the legend of a supernatural event and tells the story of the supernatural deaths surrounding the third class of junior high school. Every year, students and teachers try their best to prevent the phenomenon from happening, and the overall story echoes back and forth.

This is the first novel written by Yukito Ayatsuji, and it feels great! It's a bit unexpected that this phenomenon has not been completely solved in the end. If you do something else halfway through reading, you will still feel like you are in a book. After reading it and thinking about it carefully, there are actually a lot of foreshadowings pointing to this non-existent person.

After watching the ending, I felt relieved. The terrifying atmosphere before the mystery was revealed made me feel scared even at noon when the sun was shining. A good book that also gave me some ideas about death. The story is very cleverly designed, and the setting of non-existent people who cannot be noticed is very interesting.

The story is very good. I finally understood what I didn't understand after watching the anime before reading the novel. Unfortunately, the novel lacks the animation where Ming went to the villa and ended up getting back with the male protagonist in a swimsuit he met on the beach [smile]. I hope the author of the novel can add some information [smile]. If S is animated in the future, wouldn't the story of the swimsuit return conflict with S, but please be sure to keep Ming's swimsuit return [smile]

The ending is indeed a little more reasonable than the anime, and it's more comfortable to watch.

If I go by category, it would be reasoning by changing the case. The story is very well written with clear logic and is very interesting. There are just a few places for reasoning, but overall it is a very good novel and worth reading!

A protagonist who is obsessed with reasoning but trapped in delusions uses broken and obscure language to weave daily trivialities into a gloomy web of conspiracy. The so-called events from Mr. Kambayashi to Taji's sister are difficult to tell from fact to fact in the hesitant narrative. The truth has long given way to the compulsory logic of his inner theater. The deepest chill comes from the complete evaporation of reality. The reader is forced to alternate between sobriety and fantasy in the text. This is not a state switch, but a complete and smooth performance of his delusional personality. He tried to use the orderly framework of detective reasoning to order the chaos, but in the end he only used the bricks of reason to build a self-enclosed madhouse. Is it the fear of being replaced by others in fantasy? Is the true self usurped by a delusional personality "stand-in"? Or is each of us living under some kind of "narrative stand-in", using our own stories to replace the reality that cannot be seen directly? The state of "wanting to die but not being able to die" is the ultimate hell for delusional people - they cannot even confirm that the end belongs to them, because even "death" may be included in their fantasies as another plot.

I watched the anime a long time ago and recently finished it after seeing it on Tomato. The description of the male protagonist's psychological activities in the hotel scene at the end was so shocking that it made me feel uncomfortable. It was also very satisfying to have all the foreshadowing that had been laid before explained. Overall it's pretty good

Haha, when I found out the ending, I was still wondering if it would be reversed again. But this ending also makes me sigh. The description is concise and to the point. But I always feel that some translations are inaccurate. It is a good suspense novel that you can read in your spare time.

The whole writing style and storyline have a sense of mystery. It's just that every time someone dies, the way of death is very exciting. It's like reading a book in boredom and suddenly feeling energetic This should be a type of reasoning, right? Not as pretty as it sounds

Very interesting setting. I watched the anime many years ago and accidentally found a novel on Tomato, so I decided to catch up on it. The works written in 2009 are not outdated now, they are quite advanced novels.

It's really beautiful, and the pictures, characters, and lines are exactly the same as those of the anime. Of course, I watched the anime first and then the novel. It's so fun to read a novel while automatically filling in the animation frame by frame, haha. Master Ayatsuji's work is amazing. Not only is the plot fascinating, but the writing is also delicate and beautiful. Although it is terrifying, it is also a kind of terrifying beauty. I recommend it to everyone.

It's so good. I watched the anime first before reading the book. They are both excellent works.

Definitely a classic among suspense novels. While watching, there were constant twists and turns. In the end, I didn't expect that the non-existent person turned out to be the protagonist's aunt, Reiko Mikami. All the foreshadowing in the previous plot was recycled. The logic is strict, and it is endlessly memorable.

I think it's a bit of a mystery, and it suits my taste. It's a combination of a youth novel, a horror novel, and a mystery novel. It's a good read. Don't miss it. This is the first novel by the author that I've read. I have a good impression.

I'm going! Another substitute, Yang Persimmon, have you done this? Sure!

I really like the plot of this novel. The content is very exciting! Every little detail is an important clue, and the connection is very beautiful! See you in the next substitute!

I don't know if you guys come here to read the anime after watching it or read the novel first and then the anime. I read the anime first and then the novel!

Really invincible

I've watched the anime and came to read it.