HP: Petunia's Rose

Very well written. Especially the heroine Penny, I feel that he is a very powerful person, not in terms of external strength, but in terms of inner strength. To be honest, I really want to complain about it. I feel like many of the stand-ins in Harry Potter have very fragile minds. Voldemort's whole person mentally makes me feel like a rebellious second-stage bad boy. The professor feels like someone who is always at odds with himself. The kind of person who can never reconcile with himself. As for Dumbledore, I feel like he has been completely sealed, maybe even more powerful than Voldemort. To be honest, I don't think there are many sane people in the Harry Potter books. Back to topic. The relationship between the professor and the heroine is not abrupt at all. To the Savior Mother Lily Evans. There is no shame in being black for the sake of being black.

I stayed up all night to read it. It was a good read. I will read it next time if I like it. It was really good, and the relationship between the heroine and Professor Snape was such a warm feeling. It was really exciting. Oh my god, it felt like reading a romance novel. There wasn't too much about the magical world. It just focused on daily life. I don't know what's behind it. Will it be different? But I really like it in the early stages. Well, in the first few pictures, when the heroine was still young, the relationship between her parents and her sister might be a bit disgusting to watch. But later on, when the heroine moved out, um, and then started a sweet love, it was very special. Well, I recommend you to take a look. PS: I beg the author to read my comments. I want to know if I will abuse them later? I want to read sweet articles, thank you

A very novel setting. The heroine is reborn as a time traveler in Penny's body. As a Muggle, she indirectly participates in the first wizarding war in the British wizarding world and her love story with Snape. There's nothing wrong with the introduction. Except for the fact that the heroine is mature and rational, it can be offensive to basically everyone - it's not a complete denial of everyone (for example, Lily is still partially awakened in the later stage), but it shows everyone's human weaknesses, so readers who can't accept darkness should watch it with caution 😂 because the early stories will really be angered by the actions of many people [Petrified]

It is an easy daily HP fanfic that does not require any substitution of the original work. Even among the many settings of the White Demon, the Dark Lord, and the Professor of Hogwarts, this setting of a completely ordinary person is refreshing. And there is no such thing as saving and being saved because the male protagonist is a professor. The female protagonist initially just wanted to survive her parents' preference for their little daughter. At the beginning, it was also because the original Penny's soul did not completely leave (not intentionally) and suppressed most of the memories of the 21st century. Only some ambiguous and fuzzy memories existed, and the help of the childhood professor was also limited. It was out of kindness. After my memory was restored, I had some vague feelings for the professor. I even thought that the professor still liked Lily as much as in the original plot, so I suppressed my vague feelings. Later, I treated the professor more like a sister or a relative. In short, the story of the young love between the two of them until they confirmed their relationship made me want to stop. Hehehe... Personally, I think it deserves a high score of 5 stars. The only minor problem is that the plot details at the end may be a little unclear and incoherent due to the author's interruption for some reasons, but it does not affect the reading. Of course, the reason for the low score may be due to the author's previous discontinuous updates (it is also possible that the time-traveling character is Penny. There is some controversy in the commentary about the content of the young Lily competing for her parents' favor at the beginning of the plot, but I personally don't think there is a big problem, and it will be explained later). I hope this book will be read by the majority of HP fans. If you like it, I wish you all a happy reading~

The writing is very good, and I think Penny is already very good, why should she be treated like that because of Lily?

It's really good to read. The professor has a normal relationship, family, mother, wife, daughter, a complete home, and the description of the magical world and real life is very smooth, without any sense of contradiction. Although the daughter has time traveled and has no gold finger, she is very individual and insists on the life she wants. Regarding relationships, the family planning is very clear. It will not make the heroine be humble to the professor like some time travel novels. In a true sense, it gives the professor a love, family affection, and friendship that is in line with normal people, so it is definitely five stars! 🥰😘

I really like this novel that doesn't change Petunia's Muggle identity!!!!!

First of all, the characters in this book are relatively full-bodied, and there is no one trait throughout. The writing style is very delicate 👍 Secondly, when will I update the article? It's winter vacation. Do you want to challenge your coding speed? I think a great person like Dad can definitely double the update [Sending my heart]

It's good to watch, it's my favorite so far

The writing is generally good, and there are no surprises. Although Severus feels like he has changed too much later and is like an empty shell, at least the daily life is warm and good. Even when the prophecy appeared, I didn't like the development of the plot at first. It was too slow and had no priority. The heroine was also aware of the plot and did nothing (the birth potion came from Sif, and she didn't even reveal some prophecies to people who love her and will not betray her. Then from a God's perspective, I It was really tiring to watch Peter make trouble, and then watch Horcrux without any progress. It was really tiring to watch the heroine playing with the cat and her daughter for a long time. Although it was not very interesting, it was really good. Thank you to the author for making love.