悲伤逆流成河

I've watched the movie a long time ago, and I'm just now reading it up [face covering] The difference between the movie and the book is quite big, but the three main characters in the book are gone, leaving Gu Senxi alone to guard this cold world, which is unexpected. And the subsequent reversal of Zhong Yuan and Qin Peipei made me overwhelmed. , Similar to Yi Yao but slightly different. I like this twist very much. I think the storyline is well written, but I think some of the descriptions of the reality of life are a bit too frequent. Of course, it's just my own opinion. It's good-looking and good-looking, hehe😁😁

"Those long and dusky hours rolled back toward the sea like waves, finally revealing the remains of corpses on the beach." I have never read a modern novel that portrays the psychology of the characters so realistically. "The heart is like the setting sun in winter, falling in panic as the corners of Qi Ming's mouth suddenly lowered." What a desolate scene. The heavy sunset in winter brings out the sadness in the characters' hearts, making people feel sour. The sadness leaves indelible traces in the heart. "Overhead are criss-crossing antennas, dividing the unclear sky. The clouds float very low in the long and narrow sky. The lead-gray broken clouds cast alternating light and shadow along the alley." The long and narrow sky and the deep and shallow light and shadow create a desolate atmosphere. There is obviously light, but these days extend endlessly, until the sadness flows back into a river, and only the unclear sky above is left. "There are some things that are isolated between people, which can easily open deep ravines between each other. After it rains, it turns into a river, and there is no way to cross it. If there is heavy fog on the river again..." The warmth between people is nothing but a trivial existence, and we will never get closer to each other through tens of millions of text messages. But the festival can open a ravine, in which people's ever-changing emotions surge, stir up people's past tears, and bury the deepest and most secret pain. I'm really convinced. Now that I'm reading my comments, I feel like I'm a sucker for youth trauma literature.

2023.7.1 01:36 "Sadness flows against the river" This book belongs to the pinnacle of youth trauma literature. Yi Yao, Qi Ming, and Gu Senxiang committed suicide one after another. The world is so unfair. I hope there will never be school violence in the world. I remember reading this book when I was in high school, and I felt suffocated at that time. When I read it back now, I still feel sad, for Yi Yao, for Gu Senxiang, for Qi Ming, for Gu Senxi, for everyone except Tang Xiaomi, who was so bad. It can be said that Tang Xiaomi was the initiator of the suicide of the three of them and the mastermind of the plan! After reading this book, listen to "Under the Sea" by a durian, which captivates the world, it's so funny.

"A River of Sadness" is like a blunt knife. Although it does not hit the point of campus bullying accurately, it really cuts through the "pretense" of youth themes that only talk about sweet love, allowing everyone to see the less glamorous corners of campus. The most powerful thing about it is that it makes the matter of "being excluded by classmates" very heartbreaking. It's not the kind of violence that involves beating and killing, but intentional isolation, bad words behind your back, and secret mischief. These small actions hidden under the desk, when amplified by it, make people understand the despair of "you are surrounded by people, but you feel like you are abandoned by the whole world." Especially what the heroine yelled to everyone before jumping into the river clearly exposed the indifference of the onlookers, and it was difficult not to feel heartbroken after watching it.

I don't think this book is a romance novel. It's a book about campus bullying, true friendship on campus, and a record of some young people's heartbeats. Compared with the original work, the movie is still too conservative. The relationship between Yi Yao and her mother is relatively complicated. Lin Huafeng just didn't want her daughter to be like her, so she abused her more. Later, she knelt down to study for her daughter, made porridge to feed Yi Yao, etc. And proved that she loved Yi Yao. Qi Ming and Gu Senxi are both portrayed with flesh and blood, and their inner complexity and powerlessness are vividly and delicately portrayed. Gu Senxiang was humiliated and committed suicide, Yi Yao's mother accidentally fell and died silently, Yi Yao committed suicide in front of Qi Ming because no one trusted him, Qi Ming committed suicide by turning on the gas at home, Gu Senxi extended a helping hand after transferring to school and met Zhong Yuan but did not trust her in the end... The story seemed that everything happened too suddenly and too real. We don't have God's perspective, so we wish there would be no bullying on campus

This is the saddest novel I have ever read. I cried so much that my pillow was covered with tears. My nose was completely blocked and I could only breathe through my mouth.

It's very sensational and touching. She shouldn't abuse Yi Yao so much. Everything she does is wrong. Being strong is wrong. Compromising is wrong. I can see that, Gu Senxi and Qi Ming, it turned out that their pity for Yi Yao was just an act of empathy, because it didn't affect them. When they get involved, they will be no different from other people. Typical youth pain literature

In fact, I started watching Sadness because I watched clips from the movie. When I came to the novel, I found that I felt a strong sense of depression and breathlessness. From Yi Yao's perspective, she actually has a very unfortunate background. Her parents are divorced and her mother has a bad temper. However, Yi Yao had Qi Ming, and Qi Ming gave Yi Yao light in his dark life, and the two did not get together in the end. In fact, this ending is the most realistic. This is sadness, inescapable sadness, and real sadness.

I watched the movie first, and after reading the novel, I was greatly shocked, especially some of the psychological descriptions and narrations, and some touching little details. When I recommended this book to people around me, they always said that this book is too bloody, and the heroine is really sick, but I know that she is a person who lacks love, and I can sympathize with her. The sad point of this book is not only love, but also family and friendship. Unlike many mindless books, I think it is quite realistic.

After reading the original book, I watched the movie. My heart was broken. I felt that the original work was better. There is still some difference in the cylinder movie. Yi Yao has lost her father's love since she was a child and lives in a repressive family environment. Qi Ming helps her in life but doesn't know what this emotion is. Domestic violence and school violence push her into the abyss step by step. The only boy who brings her light does not believe her. It is very uncomfortable after watching...

Guo Jingming's writing is very strong. I think I need to slowly savor many metaphors in a second brush. I think of Yi Yao's tragic experience. She is actually very strong, but the most irreconcilable thing is that the two lights in Yi Yao's life were dazzled by pain, which was the last straw for her. This is also the most regrettable. In the end, what happened to Qi Ming is not described again. But Gu Senxi's "first-hand planning" to Zhong Yuan always feels that he still only relies on one-sided words to judge human nature, and the meaning is not yet complete. The moment I finished reading, my nose felt sour. The white space technique was too strong.

It is a classic youth pain literature. The youth that has not experienced emo for this book are all youths that are almost tasteless. Now that you've seen it, let's brush it again. It is one of the best among sadistic novels, and it is still very interesting.

After watching the movie and then reading the novel, I think Yi Yao in the original novel is braver. In the previous plot, Qi Ming's feelings for Yi Yao are just like the saying "When you are close to you, you are close to pain, and when you are far away, you are far away from happiness." After reading the original work, I couldn't relax for several days, and I never dared to open a tomato. I coaxed myself to read a few sweet articles before I dared to post this comment [face covering]

Just like those heavy sorrows, they flow back into a river along the groove circuits carved in the rings of life by each other's powerful love and powerful hatred. Guo Jingming is a writer who is particularly good at writing. He vividly describes the delicate inner feelings of 17-year-old boys and girls like me. Readers feel not only sadness, regret, and heartache, but also the pain and helplessness of being in such a background. Many things have been changed in the movie in order to be broadcast. Only words can convey the subtle and inexpressible things. The deaths of everyone in the book don't seem to come out of nowhere, and everyone's positive and negative characters are so normal and twisted. Lin Huafeng's twisted mentality of being abandoned is very real in Yi Yao's character, which can form a helpless and dazzling gap with people like Qi Ming and Gu Senxiang. My heart was so blocked that it reflected not only the problems on campus, but also the accusation and ridicule of being in such a low-level environment.

After reading the whole book, I didn't shed any tears, I just felt very depressing. From the moment Yi Yao was bullied, the whole story started to become depressing. I initially thought Gu Senxi would be the second light in Yi Yao's life, but when he didn't choose to believe Yi Yao in the end, to be honest, I could imagine Yi Yao. The despair, the so-called maternal love, his father was unwilling to see him, his two friends did not believe him, the bullying on campus, the pointing fingers of people in the alley, and the accumulation of high school coursework were enough to crush Yi Yao. In the end, three of the last four protagonists died, and the only one left did not have a good life. This book gave me the feeling of depression and sadness throughout. The writing of this book is very good and the plot is good. I still recommend everyone to read it!

I have watched both the movie version and the novel version. The movie has really changed a lot, as well as the little story at the end. There's really nothing to say about Guo Jingming's writing style. Maybe it's because I cried a lot, but I just felt sad in some places. Good-looking, love to watch, watch more

I think the character of Qi Ming is really real and three-dimensional. He breaks away from the image of the perfect male protagonist in traditional romance novels. Qi Ming is the true epitome of most ordinary teenagers. Teenagers have love and selfishness, distress and tradeoffs. Sometimes they are brave and sometimes they are cowardly and escape. This is the most attractive thing about Qi Ming. Qi Ming's love is different from Gu Senxi. Qi Ming left with strong guilt and debt. It was quite uncomfortable after watching this.

It was really touching. After watching the movie, I decided to read the novel. Unexpectedly, the plot of the novel was even more suffocating and made me very depressed. Compared to the euphemism of the movie, the novel conveys a sense of immersion in the heroine's life, and each character is uniquely depicted. Maybe the boy I grew up with only had pity for me, or maybe he once really loved me. If Gu Senxi in the movie will stand by Yi Yao unconditionally under any circumstances, Yi Yao is happy and lucky, but Gu Senxi in the novel is obviously not that likable. It can be said that Gu Senxi was saved by Yi Yao and at the same time pushed her into a deeper abyss. My favorable impression of this character gradually dropped, especially in the chapter about why the heroine did not die. The few figures made me feel that the heroine has never made a firm choice. Suffering only picks up the poor. The novel describes the misery of the heroine in detail, and the whole novel is like a tragedy!

It was like a huge wave of sadness, sweeping over and drowning everything, like an overwhelming sense of depression that was suffocating... The writing is delicate, and the description is as provocative as the plot. What came to an abrupt end was the story, but it was not such a ridiculous world forever. Perhaps in this world there are countless Yi Yao swaying like candles in the wind, countless Qi Ming shining brightly and brilliantly, countless pure jasmine-like Gu Senxiang and sunny and happy Gu Senxi... Of course, there are also countless mean Tang Xiaomi. But not all "Yi Yao" will meet a "Gu Senxi". Not all "Tang Xiaomi" will suffer the consequences. The absurd world never stops for a moment. … The only fly in the ointment is that if you don't understand it through the movie, you may feel that the later stage is slightly lacking. Lin Huafeng's death was a little unexpected, and Gu Senxiang's suicide was also more hazy. Overall, this is a good novel. The world has never been kind to itself. Drowning in the river of sadness, in this world where the journey is far away and the horses are hurried, we have never escaped.

This is a novel that makes people sigh. After reading it, I was very angry and very sad. But more of a feeling of powerlessness. When bullying occurs, it is a tragedy no matter what you do. Impressed by the author's writing style. In the end, this character creation is really fleshed out. The one who impressed me the most was Yi Yao. But the one who left the deepest impression on me was Gu Senxiang.

Read the book after watching the movie. The movie was already depressing enough, but it was only after entering the book that I experienced a new level of despair. Yi Yao was so miserable from birth to death. The cheating father, the low-class mother, the irresponsible father and the emotionally unstable mother never provided her with any support. Even the little Yi Yao endured her mother's anger and the humiliation caused by her mother's prostitution. Qi Ming and Gu Jieshi in the novel at least once illuminated a period of Yi Yao's life. But the Yi Yaos in reality can't enjoy the light at all, let alone be liked by teenagers. I really want to hug the Yi Yaos in reality. Of course, I dare not tell them that I love myself, because when a person's life is completely immersed in darkness, she does not have the conditions and ability to love herself. Just the emotion of being bullied was enough to kill her from the inside. This is not just a story of painful youth. This is a story of a girl from the bottom, a story of campus bullying, and a story of a living life struggling but gradually withering away. Life needs to be watered, life needs sunshine. There is a girl who once loved the world, gave in and endured, but later she discovered that only by fighting back under limited conditions can the world love her. I hope that everyone is not Yi Yao, and I also hope that everyone will not turn others into Yi Yao. About Qi Ming and Gu Jesse. They did worry about the girl who had nothing, and he did protect the girl who was reluctant to let go. However, all the suffering needs to be borne by Yi Yao alone. They are light but not salvation. Yi Yao needed light so much that at a special moment that light was the last snowflake before her avalanche. Girls, have light but don't depend on it. The tree that could shelter you from the wind and rain at that time will one day control your life and death like it blocks the sky and the sun.

I watched the movie when it first became popular, and now I look back at the original work. I feel really sorry for Yi Yao [almost crying] [almost crying] [almost crying] [almost crying] [almost crying]

Teacher Guo Jingming's writing style is really shocking every time I read it. He is very good at stacking gorgeous, concrete images to create atmosphere and sense of picture. Using a large number of metaphors, synaesthesia, personification, color words, light and shadow descriptions, and parallelism to impact the vision, a surreal picture with a strong subjective filter is created, which I really want to follow.

Painful yet calming, sad yet beautiful. "One generation has its own youth." In the small alleys of old Shanghai, when the evil of human nature is revealed in the darkness, and when our tears flow back into the river in the ravines of our hearts, can you still see the light? From a youth perspective, this is a sad story. From the perspective of campus bullying, this may also be enlightening to contemporary people. Please believe that dawn will always come and you will be greeted by the dawn sky.

The worlds of different boys and girls briefly overlap, then become intertwined and separated, but the fateful ties cannot be severed. The drowning man struggled. Passersby looked on. A fisherman released his pole and she grabbed it, but the fisherman let go. The water plant closest to her tried to lend a helping hand, but was dragged down with it and sank.

"A River of Sorrow" is a work with a strong background of youthful pain. Whether it is a novel or a film adaptation, it boldly tears apart the cruel side of school bullying and native families, and fully displays the helplessness, inferiority and despair of young girls surrounded by maliciousness. The fate of the characters in the story is wrapped in a gloomy atmosphere. The harm caused by the warmth and coldness of human relationships and sharp words are extremely impactful. It also makes the public truly aware of the devastating impact of cold violence, exclusion and slander on the body and mind. It has a realistic warning value that cannot be ignored. However, the overall tone of the work is too depressing and tragic, the plot tends to be extreme, the characters are created with a deliberately tragic filter, some scenes are too dramatic, and the realistic logic is lacking. The emotional expression tends to amplify pain and despair, lacking the warmth and redemption of young people growing up. The extremely sadistic narrative style also makes the overall look heavy and depressing. It is precisely because of its distinctive style that it has become a highly controversial youth-themed masterpiece.

I watched the movie a long time ago, and I thought it was very good at the time. I recently looked for a book to read, and after reading it, I thought, isn't this the original work of "Sadness Counters a River?" I must read it! What is not mentioned in the movie is that Qi Ming actually died, and Gu Senxi transferred to another school, and that Yi Yao died by jumping into a river in the movie, but in the original book, he died by jumping off a building. To be honest, I was quite angry when I watched the scene where Gu Senxi and Qi Ming misunderstood Yi Yao😡 Also, I felt that Gu Senxi was quite affectionate... Qi Ming is also quite a mommy... It's still very good-looking and worth recommending👍I like the description of Yi Yao and his family and some of the environment in the book👏 Ah ah ah, it's Qi Ming, I typed it wrong🤐

After watching it, I wanted to watch the movie again. I remember the first time I watched the movie "A River of Sorrow", I was still in the first grade of junior high school, because I was bullied by my classmates at that time, and I really felt the same way. It's depressing and painful. After reading the original work, I felt like my brain stopped for a while. I didn't expect that Qi Ming died in the end, Gu Senxi transferred to another school, and I also saw some messy things. After reading, I was confused. I was very curious about Qin Peipei and Zhong Yuan, what were they doing, were they torturing each other and taking revenge??? It was still Gu Senxi's hallucination. Someone please tell me.

I have to say that the author's writing is delicate and powerful. I particularly liked "Fantasy City" a long time ago. I read the novel first and then watched the TV series. I can really feel all the splendor of the story background from this novel. To this day, it is still unforgettable. I decided to watch the original novel "Sadness Counters a River" because I saw the movie. The film is very well-made, and it took me a long time to get over it after watching it. It was so depressing that it felt heartbreaking. It's been so long since I've been reading Banzai, and most of the cool articles have been lost in the process, but there are indeed a few books that I really like, and those few books are enough to pass the time (people who are super slow at reading...). I was looking for something new to eat today, and when I saw it, I jumped and looked at it again. Comment first and then slowly taste it, take it well, take it well, the writing is very attractive and not sloppy at all, it's worth it. Actually, I still want to briefly express my feelings after watching the movie. It turns out that Yi Yao's world is different from the alley, and there is no next chapter for the faint light.

I have watched the movie countless times, and now when I look back at the novel, I find that it is more suffocating than the movie. The novel directed by Guo Jingming is really BE, just like the "Summer Solstice Is Not Here" I watched a few years ago. The middle process is really beautiful and smooth, but it is really heartbreaking to see the end. It is still BE, well written, but the ending makes my heart unbearable [crying]