Who Killed Her (2018 Hardcover Edition)

There is only one truth, the murderer is Junichi. Here are my thoughts. Let's analyze it. At the beginning, Kaiseko said it was her fault, but she woke up and left. Then Sonoko woke up and committed suicide. Later, Junichi said that he was actually responsible for the incident and that Kaiseko was fighting for him. His reasoning was the same as Kaiseko's, that is, he woke up midway and left, and then Sonoko woke up and committed suicide. According to their words, it is impossible to tell whether Sonoko committed suicide or was killed. Later, Kaga proved that Sonoko was killed because of the testimony of the waitress upstairs. The waitress said that the lights were still on at Yuanzi's house after one o'clock in the evening. If Sonoko committed suicide, then Sonoko should take sleeping pills, set a timer (one o'clock), and then turn off the lights and go to sleep. It is impossible to leave the lights on after one o'clock. So Yuanzi was killed. Both of them are lying. Then the two of them explained that the lights were turned off the next day. Around 11:30, Junichi went to Sonoko's house first and asked her to take sleeping pills to kill Sonoko. Then she regretted after finding Sonoko's letter. At around 12 o'clock, Kaiseko, who was planning to kill Sonoko, came, and she also After reading the letter, the two decided to give up. Junichi left first, and Kasoko left the light without turning off the light. After one o'clock, the waitress saw that the light was on. Then the next day they were worried about Sonoko and came to her house to check. They found Sonoko dead, so they turned off the light and left. At this point, it is still impossible to tell whether Sonoko committed suicide or was killed, because there are three possibilities. The first is that Kaiseko decided to kill Sonoko when she was about to die, reset the timer (one point), and then left without turning off the lights. The second is that Kaiseko left without turning off the lights. Junichi went back to create an alibi, then returned to directly turn on the device to kill Sonoko, and then set the timer back to one point to create the illusion that Sonoko committed suicide (the timer was set back to one point because he had an alibi). The third type is that after Kaoshiko left, Sonoko woke up and committed suicide without turning off the lights. So there was another deadlock. Then, Kagami said that he would not let this matter go unnoticed. Then the article reads: Kang Zheng feels a little incredible, why can Kaga be so sure? He once used the testimony of the waitress living upstairs to prove that Sonoko did not commit suicide. But now, this testimony can no longer be used as a basis. Even so, why could he assert so confidently? Because Jaga knew how to tear the two medicine bags left at the scene, he concluded that Sonoko was killed. So we can think that one of the medicine bags must have been torn open by Runyi with his right hand, and the other medicine bag must have been torn open with his right hand, because Sonoko is left-handed. If Sonoko committed suicide, then the second medicine bag must have been torn with his left hand. So both medicine bags were torn open with the right hand. This is why Kaga still believes that Sonoko was killed. So the real murderer tore open the medicine bag with his right hand. Apparently Kang Zheng also realized that the reason why Kaga was so sure lay in the way he tore the two medicine bags. That is right, right. But Kaga didn't know which hand Kayoko used to tear the medicine bag, so he said the answer was not revealed. Even if Kayoko also used her right hand to tear the medicine bag, it would still be impossible to tell who the murderer was. But Kang Zheng saw the process of Jiashizi tearing the medicine bag. And he said that the answer has been revealed, which means that he already knows who the real murderer is. Then there is only one possibility, that is, Kaiseko tore the medicine bag with her left hand. That is right, right, left. The real murderer is Junichi! I have read this book three times. When I read it for the first time, I was completely confused. I had no idea who killed her. I didn't know the details in the book at all. I searched online and found all the answers. The murderer was Junichi, the murderer was Kaiseko, and some thought it was Sonoko who committed suicide. All of them were reasonable and well-founded. The second time I read it, I was more careful. I was worried that I couldn't remember some details at the time, so I wrote them all down on paper. I carefully deduced the real culprit, and finally came to the conclusion that the real culprit was Junichi. This made me feel extremely excited and proud, and I felt that I resonated with the author. This is the third time I have read this book. It has been a long time. The speed is much faster, the ideas are clearer, and I feel the charm of this book even more. I sincerely recommend this book, it's very, very good!

I asked why there was no difficulty level at the beginning and two suspects were identified so quickly. It turned out to be to let readers find the answer on their own in the end. This design is very interesting, but to be honest, I don't like open endings when reading mystery novels. Even if there is obvious pointing evidence, I still hope that the book can have an accurate answer with a beginning and an end. Otherwise, even if I guess the murderer, I will not be disappointed. Apart from the case itself, I am really not interested in the meaningless love-hate relationship between the three people in the book. But I understand Yuanzi's mood very well, and I admire her for being able to stop herself from the brink when she is blinded by hatred. "Even if I sell my soul to the devil so that you two can't get together happily, in the end, I will still get nothing, only an empty shell that has abandoned my human self-esteem." The whole book only resonates with this sentence. Stay away from garbage people and know how to let go.

A deceased person and two suspects embarked on a journey to pursue the truth with their own goals and objectives. Keigo Higashino is indeed Japan's famous and world-renowned master of suspense reasoning. The setting of the reasoning links and the suspense design are meticulous and surprising. The author's unique writing style and writing characteristics amaze readers in terms of case presentation and suspenseful reasoning. At the same time, it is also mixed with reflections and thoughts on life and human nature. The storyline is compact, highly interesting and readable.

Who killed her? The horror of human nature, the former best friend, the former lover, all invariably murdered her. After the lover arranged the suicide scene, the two regretted and left after their best friend came, and then when the ex came back, he faked the suicide and successfully committed the murder. When I was watching the first half, I never understood why I would kill someone just because of my lover. It wasn't until I saw the video recorder and the tapes that I realized that it was the case. Sonoko gave up in the end because I defeated the devil because of my pure soul, but my ex didn't give up. If you really gave up, why didn't you erase all traces when you left, and why did you give Yuanzi a chance to commit suicide? For Yuanzi, no one can be relied on except her brother.

"Who Killed Her" by Keigo Higashino is a thought-provoking mystery novel. With its unique narrative technique and open-ended ending, it keeps readers guessing during the reading process and leaves suspense until the end. The novel begins with the death of Izumi Sonoko, who was found to have died by suspected suicide, but her brother Izumi Yasumasa was convinced that it was murder. Kang Zheng decided to cover up the flaws at the scene, making the police mistakenly believe that it was a suicide case, and at the same time began to investigate on his own. The background of the story is set in realistic tenement apartments and streets, and the motivations often stem from "impulse", which makes the story more realistic. As the investigation deepens, Kangzheng identifies two suspects: Sonoko's ex-boyfriend and best friend Yumba Kayoko. However, during the investigation, detective Kyouichiro Kaga discovered that whether it was Kang Zheng, Sonoko's ex-boyfriend or Kayoko, they were all lying. This cat-and-mouse game makes readers nervous and full of curiosity. The ending of the novel does not clearly reveal who the murderer is, but allows readers to figure out and infer on their own through Kang Zheng's actions and Kaga's reasoning. This open ending is the charm of "Who Killed Her". It allows every reader to become a detective and solve the mystery based on the clues in the book. Through this story, Keigo Higashino demonstrates his deep understanding of human nature and keen insight into social phenomena. After reading this book, you will find that the real murderer may not be important. What is important is the complexity of human nature and the blurring of moral boundaries revealed in the story. Overall, "Who Killed Her" is a thought-provoking work that challenges the traditional mystery novel model and leaves readers with a broad space for thinking. It is not only a mystery novel, but also an exploration of the dark side of human nature. If you like mystery novels and like to challenge your thinking, this book is definitely worth reading.

Who knows if I can only read the first chapter?

It's cool, but no matter who is the murderer, one of them indirectly killed the protagonist. So it actually means that the two of them jointly committed the murder. Because when you have the intention to kill, then you are only one step away from killing. Keigo Higashino uses the perspective of the protagonist's only relative, his brother, to write about the life and psychology of his brother who did not care about his sister, which led to her being killed. Through his investigation, he got very close to the truth, and finally found the final murderer with the help of Officer Kaga.

In fact, I still feel that White Night Walk is more shocking to me because there are so few characters and it's easy to guess them, but I haven't seen the motivation of the shrimp yet. It's Sonoko! Why do you make small movies? Those two are too open-minded (although there is no explosion in Byakuya Yui and I don't know their names very well. Forgive me, this article is too short) I have the opportunity to read all of Higashino Keigo~ I like it~

I watched it a long time ago, and I remember that Junichi is left-handed because he carries his backpack on his left shoulder. This was a subconscious reaction, and there was no mention of Junichi using his right hand. Kaiseko drinks coffee with her left hand, but writes with her right hand, and the handwriting is clean and beautiful. I think Kaiseko is likely to be able to use both left and right hands freely.

This is a novel that requires readers to find the answer on their own. Keigo Higashino's "Secret", "White Night Journey", "Relief Grocery Store", "Street of Dawn", "The Devotion of Suspect X", etc. Are all famous. This book may not seem famous, but it is very exciting. It is also the first novel by Keigo Higashino that I have read. This book tells the story of traffic policeman Kang Zheng who rushed from Nagoya to Tokyo, but the last thing he saw was his sister's body. Everything at the scene looked like suicide, but Kang Zheng found signs of homicide. How did Kang Zheng solve the puzzle? It is up to the readers to find out the answers themselves.

The title of the book is interesting and extremely attractive, attracting readers' interest in reading. The author uses ingenious plot weaving and complex character relationships to draw readers into a gripping mystery. The story is filled with unexpected twists and surprising revelations, keeping readers on edge throughout. This book is full of suspense and mystery, and is so engrossing that it's hard to put it down. If you are interested in suspense, be sure to read this book!

It's very suspenseful and worthy of the Kaga series.

The main key is three bags of sleeping pills: labeled abc Hypothesis ① Suicide: Then the sleeping pill b was opened by Yuanzi, leaving traces of Yuanzi ②Tian Runyisha: then ab sleeping pills leave traces of male opening, c is Jia Shizi ③Jia Shizi kills: bc leaves the same traces, a is the trace of Tsukuda Junichi Among them, it can be ruled out through the brother's reaction in the last chapter ①. The brother finally wanted to confirm the traces. As for his final reaction, I am more inclined to speculate that it was Tsukuda Junichi. The open ending requires trace comparison, and anyone can do it.

I think Kang Zheng in this book is undoubtedly a very annoying person. He is suspicious and domineering. He always wants to judge other people's thinking according to his own way of thinking. In fact, it is a bit like not doing to others what you don't want others to do to you. He always thinks that he is very smart, and implements this intelligence into investigating cases. He always feels that things are very complicated. In fact, this is a simple suicide case. But because of Kang Zheng's own unrealistic ideas, he will always doubt others until others tell lies to confirm his own ideas. He himself feels that his own sense of vanity is satisfied. In fact, he is a complete hypocrite from the beginning to the end. In fact, his sister, I think, is not very important to him. He just uses his sister as an excuse to satisfy someone he wants. In fact, he really lacks a sense of social value and recognition in his heart. I feel that it is because he has some psychological problems and lacks recognition from others, so he has always made others uncomfortable in this way, including when he pretended to be a criminal police officer to investigate. The way he spoke was indeed not very pleasant. I have met similar people in my life, and I would avoid them. Sometimes such characters are very unreasonable and want to constantly trouble others. In fact, I feel that this book by Keigo Higashino is a bit like a writing technique, which is to tell you the ending in advance, but not the process, so that the audience can first There is an ending, but at the same time there is a suspense. Why is there an ending? So many words are spent on this ending. I think it is because I want to make this seemingly simple ending more smooth and rational, so I added some details.

I watched it in the college entrance examination. I was addicted to success. I lost nearly 100 points in the college entrance examination [Like]

The hypotheses and debates in the last two chapters are immersive, but confusing, and you can't tell who is right and who is wrong, and the final solution is based on the details, which makes people suddenly realize it and sigh, "How can you see this?" It's so exciting [Like]

The murderer should be Junichi, and Gongzi is left-handed. According to the order of tearing the medicine package, it should be right, right, left. Only in this way can we find out who the murderer is.

The murderer is Tsukuda Junichi. Based on the last conversation between Kaga and Yasumasa, we can analyze the premise that Sonoko did not commit suicide but committed suicide. Judge based on the three left- and right-handed habits of tearing apart sleeping pill packets. Sonoko is left-handed. Right, right, left is the only answer. Only the first two times when Kaeko tore the medicine package with his right hand, and the last one when Kaeko tore it with his left hand, is the only answer to the murder.

I don't know much about the culture of the novel. I thought that my brother was covering up clues to find the murderer in order to kill the murderer. While reading, I had a vague feeling that he would not kill the murderer, but in the end, he did not kill the murderer. My brother said that maybe as long as he knew who the murderer was, then, if the clues were not covered up, the police would not conclude that it was suicide and would investigate the case. In the end, my brother would still know who the murderer was. If it is to change the mind of the murderer who killed him, in fact, during the process, I did not feel the brother's strong desire to avenge his sister from the description. As for the comments in the comment section that my sister wants to expose what Kaeko did in the past because of a man, I want to say, if your friend pried your partner away, wouldn't you be resentful? And in the end, my sister did not record the video. I think a person who has been "betrayed" should be allowed to have the urge to "retaliate." If there is no such resentment, I can only think of the following things: 1. You don't have that deep affection for the person who has already met the other person's parents. 2. You have known from a very early age that your "friend" may "steal" your things, so you have long been prepared to be snatched away by him. 3. You love your boyfriend, and you feel heartbroken and unbelievable about the double betrayal of your friend and lover, but you are destined to be a "big Buddha", so you choose to "bless" them . Well, the sister in the article has a deep affection for her boyfriend and regards Yoshiko as her only close friend, and she is obviously not a "big Buddha", so she has the idea of ​​revenge on these two people she trusts, which is reasonable, but in the end she said that she was unwilling to give her soul to the devil, but she would not forgive them, but she was killed in the end. Conclusion: Those who say that my sister has a cat cake, and "do this to a friend for the sake of a man", Why not say that Kaeko betrayed her relationship with her sister for a man? Of course, that Junichi is not a good person, he is crazy and his feelings are transferred too quickly [awkward laugh]

Who is the murderer [crying] [crying] [crying] heart-wrenching

Great mystery novel

The final design was unexpected

I bought a physical copy of this book when I was in junior high school. After reading it, I always thought that the murderer was Yoshiko Yumba. Now that I read it again, I realized that I had misunderstood. In fact, the murderer was Junichi Tsukuda.

Human nature is really complicated sometimes, but when viewed alone, it is so simple, so simple that if you don't do it for yourself, you will be punished by heaven and earth!

After reading Keigo Higashino's book, I felt sublimated again.

The reasoning process is quite exciting. Although it does not reveal who the murderer is, you will have the answer after reading it.

The plot of this book is really fascinating, just like after I gave birth to a child, life became complicated, and I also needed to find the truth like the protagonist in the book. Moreover, Higashino Keigo's writing style is very unique, which kept me guessing who the murderer was, and the answer was not revealed until the end. I think this book is worth reading, especially for those who like mystery novels.

The plot is quite delicate and there are a lot of foreshadowings, you can take a look

Very good, highly recommended

Don't tell me, I really like it