The Gate of the Firmament

Tragic Xianxia! The Kind That Tears Your Heart to Pieces! Make It Hurt! Make It Hurt! Make It Hurt!

Looking for a Story Where One Is Happy to Hit and the Other Is Happy to Take It. Any Gender

Any Gut-Wrenchingly Angsty Stories? I’m Begging You!

Looking for books similar to After Transmigrating into a Book, I Was Led Astray by the Villain. I want a really humble, submissive male lead. Historical or modern settings are both fine, and a little angst would be great. Even a lot of angst is fine. Please, I’m begging you.

Tragedies, the More Heartbreaking the Better. I've Finished Seven Already, Give Me More Pain

Angsty Cultivation Novels!!! Please!

Looking for Novels With Physical Abuse

I want books similar to Discipline: White Night (Physical Torture Edition). Any genre is fine, as long as there's physical torture.

Looking for Stories Where the Male Lead Gets Beat Up and Slapped, Then Trained Like a Dog. He Should Be Unwell.

Looking for books like The Good Girl Went Too Far Training the Dog: She Slapped Him and Made Him Lick Her Palm.

Looking for Brutal Physical Torture Without Emotional Anguish

Looking for books like "Your Majesty, the Shadow Guard Knows His Mistake and Begs for Punishment". Are there any that are physically brutal but not emotionally angsty? I want something harsh.

Torture the Male Lead, Torture Him Mercilessly

I want the male lead to suffer, physically and emotionally, from head to toe and inside out.

Any Recommendations for Stories with Torture and Physical Abuse?

Looking for Stories Where the Male Lead Suffers Both Mentally and Physically, Then the Couple Reconciles

Looking for books like Bone-Eroding Crisis. Something with the roles reversed: instead of the man hurting the woman, the woman hurts the man, followed by a second-chance romance with a happy ending.

Recommend Me Tragic Stories That Hurt So Much They Tear Your Heart to Pieces

Ideally rated over 9!