Wild Geese Sing and Autumn Comes

This book is really good. I didn't expect to see such a literary book on Tomato. I feel it is very suitable to be turned into a TV series. It is really a treasure. It took me a few days to read it. It is really interesting. I didn't expect that the score was not high. Compared with some inexplicable 9.9, This book's score is really low.

After reading it all afternoon, I felt that it was very realistic and well written, Gone with the Wind in the feudal period. It's just a pity that it's being serialized, I'll add it to my bookshelf and wait to read it! Come on, author!

Use your free time to read from beginning to end, and feel the joy, anger, sorrow, and joy throughout. I feel that the author's thinking is clear, not muddled, and truly reproduces the difficulty of the two sisters of the Shen family in the 1920s from being sold to walking out of their different wonderful lives. In the end, justice defeats evil in this novel, which is always full of positive energy. If it is made into a TV series, the effect will probably be even better! Thank you to the author for providing us readers with such a good work, which is worth reading. I don't know why, but it's a pity that the rating is not high. I hope the author will have better works to dedicate to readers in the future.

Excellent writing! It was as if I had witnessed every detail of this family...

Sincere and natural, the characters are well-drawn!

Wonderful and beautiful, it can be regarded as a good book

The plot of the love novel Gone with the Wind in the Republic of China is particularly good, with each link linking one link to another.

It's so wonderful. In the current age where online novels such as fantasy, time travel, getting rich overnight, flying on a branch and becoming a phoenix, etc., Are raging, it is not easy to read such a wonderful, tragic, patriotic, despising death, and sacrificing one's life for the sake of the nation without hesitation. It is really not easy. I will recommend it to book lovers! It is an excellent work that will make people's blood boil when watching it. It is worth recommending.

The plot has ups and downs and is gripping. Don't miss it!

The plot of the story has ups and downs, and the characters in the novel value love and justice. Although it is sad, the ending is still happy! Very nice! [Like][Like][Like]

It's totally ready for a TV series, the characters are full. The story is compact

Thanks to the author, who not only has excellent writing skills but also understands history. I believe that what is written in this novel really happened. National crisis is at hand. The love, hatred and fearless patriotism of a group of ordinary people. It is precisely because of the contributions of thousands of predecessors that we have the comfortable life we ​​have now.

It is a rare novel in the Internet. The author has profound literary skills, the writing style is delicate but not ostentatious, the plot is profound and graceful, the life experiences of the sisters are reasonable, and the characters are not thin. It is worth reading!

The story is close to life, making it easy for the audience to accept it. Thank you to the author for his careful creation, which allows readers to feel the story's affectionate, touching, interesting, and exciting plot. I read each chapter carefully and I have not read the entire text yet, hoping for a happy ending.

I like it very much. The plot is ups and downs but reasonable and fascinating. If there is a feeling of family and country behind it, I feel it can be made into a TV drama.

The plot of the story is ups and downs, several lines echo each other, and the relationship between the characters is very prominent. This novel revolves around the Qiu Shuang family. The growth of the Qiu Shuang sisters in personal experience, and the people around them who value love, justice, family and country, and justice and bravery, all left a deep impression on people! Highly recommend this novel.

It should be very nice to make into a TV series. The author's writing is very delicate and the content is very visual. I just think it's very beautiful, and without the author's great writing style, I can't write a better review [face covering]

A book that embodies the descendants of the Yan and Huang Dynasties. The author describes the plot of the story very delicately. It reflects the patriotism of the Chinese people with flesh and blood. It is a good book worth reading [Like][Like][Like]

A good work with feelings about family and country as well as human love, worth reading.

The plot of this book is full of ups and downs, not bad, and beautiful. In such a war-torn era, there are feelings of family and country, some love between children, some love and righteousness, and each has different life experiences. Although the two sisters of the Shen family were born poorly, they both changed their destiny through their own efforts. This allowed them to live the life they wanted, and at the same time, they also gained their own happy love. Although the content is poignant, the ending is perfect.

The author is so talented. The opera, poetry, calligraphy and painting, and antiquities are all well described. The story characters and historical background complement each other. The war is not a war drama, and the romance is not romance. The light and dark lines intersect and finally merge into one line. In addition, the emotional real-life narration is even more fascinating!

It is worth seeing that no matter what life experiences of soldiers and ordinary people, their overcoming difficulties, human warmth and patriotism are admirable. The plot is compact and the characters are vividly drawn. This book is worth reading.

Wonderful! The two sisters can be regarded as meeting noble people, and more importantly, they worked hard to change their lives, interspersed with love, hatred, family and country, until the final happy ending. It's like drinking a glass of old wine, with endless aftertaste.

(Listened + finished watching on March 29, 2025) The story is very good, the plot is compact, the characters are distinct, family, friendship, love, family and country are well expressed! The voice of the live audio book host is nice. Recommend! (Asuka stays)

Beautiful and wonderful. If it is made into a TV series, it will definitely get high ratings [Like][Like][Like][Like]

The historical figures have a sense of reality, and the background characters are diverse. A very good book!

The author writes very objectively about a specific historical period, with both lingering and sweet love and tragic feelings about his family and country! Worth a look! I even hope it can be made into a TV series! It must be very exciting

The author's writing is very good. The wandering life of the three Shen siblings in troubled times may be a microcosm of the lives of most people in that era. The reality is more cruel than the book. After all, the ending of the three siblings is good. The important characters are not perfect and are not absolutely good or bad. In that era when the country has to survive in the cracks, every patriot who has ever stood up and resisted deserves to be respected.

Clear context, a rare good book

The writing is delicate, the plot is compact, and the chapters are rich and fascinating.