With Smoke

This book is really suitable for old bookworms, especially when you are a little tired of reading and can't find the book you want to read. It fits your taste in every aspect and is very good. I have been wanting to read novels recently, but I can't find what I want to read. I found a few books and felt tired after reading them. I feel that the text is very long and long. This one is great, short, but it shows everything the reader wants to read. This is my first time writing a book review and I really like it! ! !

He is a very gentle male protagonist. He loves the female protagonist very much. No matter in the past life or in this life, the extra story made me cry [crying] [crying] Fortunately, the main text is very sweet [loving] The author's writing style is very good👍🏻

This is the first novel that amazed me after reading "Spring Banquet". There is no intrigue in the article and there is no abuse throughout. It is very sweet. It deserves this rating. Of course, I think it is okay to rate it 9.9. In short, this is a novel that you will regret to death if you don't read it. Very very beautiful

The extra story is so touching that I can't stop crying. It's as if the stories in the book are more than just stories...

The writing is good and doesn't drag. Very good. I just can't agree with the author's ideas, and I feel like I can't sympathize with the heroine and the heroine's sister-in-law at all. A child committed suicide when she was about to give birth, leaving one dead and two dead; a former official lady, who had fallen into prostitution but never lost her virginity, felt ashamed of herself in front of a bandit leader? Suffering yourself and others, you feel like enjoying your own suffering. To put it bluntly, he is cowardly, incompetent and selfish. Asking for trouble. Moreover, there is no progress at all in rebirth, and there are many hardships in life. Will we really be able to grow old together in peace in the second life? Character determines destiny! Alas, there is indeed everything in dreams. I hope the author will sort out his thoughts and make persistent efforts to write a good book with three correct views.

Before I read it, what could make me cry about a romance story? After reading the extra, I almost burst into tears. The author is so amazing. The language may seem bland but every sentence is heart-wrenching!

Wuwuwu, the rating of 9.5 Is not for nothing. It is really beautiful. The full text is not too long. It is just right. The writing style is also very delicate and smooth. If it ends with the past life, wuwuwu, it would be so good to cry.

With a gentle and pious heart, I slowly immersed myself in the intoxicating fragrance of peach blossoms under the bright moon on a summer night. The soft brushstrokes, delicate writing style, and touching passion are all buried in the tears and smiles of the people in the story. The peach blossom tree is the place of origin and the place of sleep together. I slowly fall in love with you, slowly and slowly. It may happen at first sight, or it may make you drunk, but after the love starts, it will be strong. We may be separated, but we will reunite in the end and stay together. All the members of the previous life were basically be. Although it is a side story, the emotional line is not as polished as the main story, but it is indeed more impactful. The tragic beauty is extremely impactful. Compared with the vigorous and earth-shaking sacrifice of love, their dull, helpless and slow-burning love tragedy is more heart-stirring. "Whether it's the past life or this life, if you die, I will naturally not live alone. You left me alone in this world, which is the biggest punishment for me. I will accept the punishment for not protecting you and failing to protect the people you love. You made me suffer the most bone-crushing pain in the previous life, and I will accept it." All the characters in this life are basically he. Although it is the main text, the narrative is interspersed with fragments of the past life, but the huge contrast between the two lives also makes people sigh and regret. This clarity breaks out at the end. Although the language is plain, every word is heartbreaking. "Yes. Why are you crying? The days are getting better day by day. Everyone is safe. Why are you crying?" Finally, whether judging from the perspective of tragic aesthetics or comedy aesthetics, the legendary and touching nature of the story cannot be denied. The person in the book is the person reading the book, and the visitor is passing by after reading it. I wish everyone in the book stay safe and stay together. With a gentle and pious heart, I slowly watched the drunken peach blossom tree blossom and decline year by year. [Sending Hearts]

After reading it, I felt quite shocked. It is really beautiful and exciting. Fortunately, what Liu Yunzhi said was not true. Yu Yan did not go to the underworld after his death, but pursued the perfection of this life with the regrets of the previous life. It must be that their obsessions were both deep, so they met again... After Yu Yan committed suicide, he was reborn seamlessly, with a lot less pain. What was uncomfortable was that Liu Yunzhi in his previous life was depressed alone for seven years for his nephew. The author's writing style is very good, and the plot is not sloppy at all and is very capable. Although it does not involve the high-ranking and powerful tactics, it looks better than those books, and it feels like a lot of flowers emerge from the clear water. Hmm... Let me add one more thing, the car drives pretty steadily.

It's super beautiful, short, concise, and touching. Fortunately, I was reborn, and fortunately, HE. When I saw the previous life, I almost fainted in the toilet from crying [I almost cried] [I almost cried] [I almost cried] It's the kind that I can't bear to delete after watching it

I am a very impatient person, but I read this novel from beginning to end. The plot is engaging but not draggy, and the pace is a little fast but just right for me. The love between the male and female protagonists is not earth-shattering, but more like a steady stream. They will always love each other deeply. And if you like gentle male protagonists, I highly recommend this one. They really made me cry to death in their previous lives, but luckily they are sweet in this life. I believe that people who love each other will always be favored by God... Wuwuwu, Liu Yunzhi and Yu Yan will be together forever. I believe that people who love each other will never have bad luck.

The author is great! It's all finished and it made me shed so many tears! There are not many chapters, but they are very delicate. You can feel the love between the male and female protagonists between the lines! Nice! [Adoration] Occasionally, there is a little bit...🤫Hmm! Perfect

Liu Yunzhi: "If you leave, I will follow you." Yu Yan: "The exquisite dice are decorated with red beans, and I miss you deeply." It is very sweet, unforgettable love, some are so sweet that they also cry. I wish all lovers love you and your family ❤️❤️

It's very interesting, the story is concise, there is no intrigue, the male and female protagonists are destined to be related in both lives, the sweet love, it is the best extra story that made me cry, the male protagonist is really great.

It's great. This extra story describes the life of the male protagonist after the heroine left in the previous life. I really cried a lot. The two of them were buried in the soil under the peach blossom tree in the final ruins. I cried so hard. Although they died in the previous life, they will be together forever. Wuwuwuwuwu. After a few years, I re-read it. I have experienced more and felt more. Liu Yun fell in love with Yanyan in his previous life, but they met too early. Liu was just a top scholar, powerless and allowed others to suppress him. He wanted to resist, but he had Yanyan, and he wanted to protect Yanyan's brother and Yu Zhai. , But he is just a civil servant with no power or military strength at all. He wants to keep his Yanyan, but his Yanyan has long been covered with wounds due to his incompetence. He loves her, but she is gone, and the young man's only treasure disappears, leaving only a vicissitudes of life. Is it because the young man has not worked hard enough? Do they not love each other enough? ... It's really helpless and realistic...

Wuwuwu, I cried so much in the extra chapter😭, although the full text seems to be a plain and simple story without any twists and turns, it is better than this kind of plainness. For them, this kind of plainness is the happiest, most beautiful and most dreamed of life [crying]

Wuwuwu yyds, the first part was a bit sad, and it can be said that the whole process was full of aunt laughter. The second half is an extra story, which also supplements the story of the heroine before her rebirth in the first half. Although the tears did not flow in a loud stream, they were clear tears in several lines. The emotions between the characters were described very delicately. I love Wuwu so much. This book will be moved to my "completed bookshelf". I will not delete it and will read it again in the future! ! I love the author so much, I write so well that the needle doesn't poke me, and my pen refills °-♡

It's really beautiful. The exquisite dice and the red beans make me miss you so much. The bitterness of the past life and the sweetness of this life may always be sweet. I hope each of us can meet the love of Yu Yan and Mr. Liu in this life.

The emotions of each character are very good. There is emotion in the ordinary. The scholar didn't know that she was actually scared to death. She is afraid of Yu Zhai and Yu Hongyi. But I am even more afraid that he will not be able to read the book he wants and that he will be unhappy.

Overall, it's a good work. There are no male and female protagonists who are stronger than others. It is true that they are ordinary. I am used to seeing plots with ups and downs, and when I watch a work like this, only the most sincere and passionate feelings run through it. You can still read the short works. Recommend.

Like him? This novel has a happy ending, which is very sweet. (Don't watch it) Like be? This novel is so tear-jerking that both the male and female protagonists have died. (You can watch the show directly) This novel has [shyness] in the way you like it. The author wrote this story very carefully (beep quietly: the car drives very well). Every supporting character in the book also has feelings and meanings. Hmm... This book can be put on the "I like" bookshelf~ You won't lose money if you invest, I swear!

The extra is really touching. Their life seems to have really happened in a place we don't know. I hope Ayun and Xiao Yaner are safe and happy o(*＾▽＾＊)o♪ I hope Xiao Yuer's family is happy and healthy! Goodbye, Liu Yunzhi, Yu Yan

The plot is very simple, straight to the point without so many twists and turns, a simple and plain love. Yu Yan has changed many things in his previous life after his rebirth, but the only thing that has not changed is his love for Liu Yunzhi. The same is true for Liu Yunzhi. As sweet as the main text is, the extra chapter is as sad as it is.

Very good, very eloquent, just like a storyteller. There is no misunderstanding between the male and female protagonists, there is no bloodshed, they truly love each other. I just feel that the heroine is too selfish and commits suicide even after giving birth to a child. I think she is very cruel to both the hero and the child!

The overall feeling of this book is good. The male protagonist has a strong sense of responsibility. He is really from heart to action, and he is really good to the female protagonist. I always feel that the male protagonist's variables are the guiding force that promotes changes in the original story. The male protagonist in this book pays more than the female protagonist. The content is good, the plot is compact, the emotions are delicate, not shocking, but comforting. It is a bit of a knife in the past life, but don't worry, the heroine in the past life did not think about it, and the knot in her heart was slowly untied after rebirth. It is still satisfactory. Every character who regretted in the previous life has been fulfilled in this life. The above is just my personal experience, please point out if there are any deficiencies. I don't like to squirt in a hurry [laugh awkwardly] [laugh awkwardly]

The heroine's rebirth changed her brother's ending. She didn't have much wisdom and ended with the male protagonist. I wanted to give the story four stars, but I read the extra. It narrated the first life in a short and concise way. It was very exciting and made me cry. After reading it, I felt lost and helpless from the bottom of my heart. If I open this book again, I hope to read the extra first and then read the main text, so that I will feel very comfortable. After all, the sweet ending is very healing. Be sure to watch the extras first! ! ! Read the text again. Otherwise, if the energy is too strong, I will end up with edema on the second day [almost crying]

The extra is really awesome! The main text seems to be bland, and the foreshadowing is useful. My eyes 👀 have never been fucked while watching the extra story. Even when the heroine committed suicide, her emotions reached the peak. She couldn't breathe due to crying, with a lot of snot and tears. When I saw the male protagonist, I knew that the heroine's emotions had reached a breakdown. At the top of the world, he knew he couldn't stop anything, but he still didn't believe what he was seeing. At that moment, he didn't know whether to feel sorry for the heroine or the hero. Alas, they were both miserable people in the world. It was really because of suffering that they had the next life. The subconscious ending was perfect٩(˃̶͈̀௰˂̶͈́)و

Simple and beautiful, innocent and simple, profound and unforgettable They were together in the previous life, but because the heroine's brother and a large village of people died, the heroine dreamed every night, and the sadness flowed back into the river. She suffered physical and mental torture, couldn't hold on, and committed suicide. After the heroine committed suicide, the hero also went there after raising the heroine's nephew. Never forget her death, never let go of the sadness After rebirth, the male and female protagonists reach the end of their lives sweetly, and the heroine's brother and lover finally get married. Everything is beautiful and dreamy. This is probably what everyone wants, everything is fine.

It's really beautiful. The relationship between the two of them is really good, but the extra chapter is really emo [almost crying] [almost crying] [almost crying] [almost crying]. The author's writing is very good. The whole book is flowing and warm. It's really hard not to love it.

I stayed up late to finish reading it. I once thought it was ridiculous just by reading the introduction, but after reading it, I really enjoyed it. The author's writing style is very delicate. It's a book I particularly like. Even the little character is portrayed very well by the author. Whether it is Liu Yunzhi and Yu Yan, or Yu Hongyi and Lian Bingyan, or even the scholar couple in the village, the author writes them very well, making people feel that they are not just paper characters, but actually exist in another world. Liu Yunzhi and Yu Yan must live happily in this life. As mentioned at the end of the novel, everything will get better and better.