Songs in the Clouds (Three Volumes)

It took me a few days to finish reading Yunzhongge, and I feel that Tonghua's writing skills are even better than those of Desert Ballad. This book is a typical tragedy. Belinsky said: "Accidentality has no place in tragedy. In art, tragedies that are realized by accidents, car accidents, and accidents are not good tragedies. A truly good tragedy is when everything is logical, everyone is normal, and even kind, and things still slide irrevocably toward collapse. There are no winners and no survivors." This book is a very typical example. I think Yunzhongge, Bubu Jingxin, and Langya Bang are the top three tragedies in my mind, and they all fit Belinsky's passage very well. I still have lingering fears about that sense of powerlessness. I was very angry about some plots in the book, but as I read, I realized that I had no way to prevent this plot from happening, not even Yun Ge, nor the author. I could only smile and watch it collapse step by step. It was indeed depressing after reading it, but I was finally able to exhale, let out a long sigh, and felt relieved. I love and hate many characters in the book. When I hate them, I hope they die, but when I love them, I respect them. I can't even blame them, because every move they make has a reason. They have enough reasons to make this decision, and there is no other better choice for public or private purposes. Things just slipped into the abyss step by step... All in all, this is a good book, with impeccable plot, writing, characters, and background. Tonghua, as expected of you.

This is the third time I have watched it, and I feel very sorry for Liu Fulin.

The writing is thick and fascinating, the plot is ups and downs, and the expressions are sincere and touching. It is just too sadistic. I felt heartbroken and cried constantly when I read it. It is a good work, but I dare not read it a second time. The most sincere and pure love in the world is yearning, but the pain of separation also makes people heartbroken. The portrayal of Brother Ling by Yunge is too perfect, too full, and it is difficult to calm down. Maybe every girl hopes to have a Brother Ling, even if they go through a certain stage of life together. I also want to have Meng Jue, who will take care of me and take care of me all the way through life. But life is not a novel. You can only feel this most sincere love, care and companionship in novels. 2022.11.20

After reading it over and over again, it would be great if the author could write a spin-off so that Liu Fulin could be like Huo Qubing and travel around the world with Yun Ge to become a couple of gods and gods, so as to comfort our regrets as readers. I still prefer more happy endings [laughs][laughs][laughs]

The two books "Ballad of the Desert" and "Song of the Clouds" are like taking us into the long river of history, feeling the power of powerful officials, the flash of swords in the court, Huo Yunbing, under the attack of several forces, chose to die after regaining the country. Liu Fulin was intelligent and kind. He ascended the throne at the age of eight and made great achievements in his thirteen years of reign. It's a pity that he died in the conspiracy of powerful ministers. Fortunately, they both met Qingyu and Yunge. Although these two women experienced love and hatred in their emotions and were heartbroken, they still accompanied the loved ones in their hearts in their own different ways. Find your own peace and happiness. Although Shangguan Xiaomei and Meng Jue have relatively tragic fates, they both have kind hearts. Although their obsessions cannot be realized, they persevere without any regrets. Liu Xun was too ruthless and betrayed many people. Meng Jue gave him a lot of support, including educating his son, and he didn't let him go. It seems that everyone is obsessed with his throne. In general, Wen Tonghua's articles are very well written, and they are all excellent in terms of writing style, artistic conception, and emotion. And not a single typo.

The content of each of the author's novels is rich in layers, and the characters are vivid and vivid. After reading it, I have mixed feelings... I won't say more words of praise. The heroine is not very likable because she is stupid and sweet in love. Apart from being an expert at cooking, she is not good at learning anything else despite having such good resources. She does not understand many of her obsessive behaviors, but it is normal that she did not end up with Meng Yu in the end. A good horse will not turn back, not to mention that he is still a person who has deeply hurt himself. You cannot pretend that the harm never happened just because you made up for it later. The most innocent and innocent first relationship is the most precious, because it is unreserved, so once it is let down, it will be the deepest hurt. Even if time can dilute everything, it will always be imprinted on the heart like a scar on the back, always proving that those things happened. Good times are always at your fingertips. The sweet and cruel part with Liu Fuling has made readers cry so much that they can cry until they convulse. This is the author's consistent style. The extreme sweetness is bitter... Liu Xun's portrayal is very real. The character created by the environment in which he grew up and the emperor's grand cause will not last long unless he is ruthless. It's similar to unofficial history but also like the original history. I really admire the author's writing skills. I feel so tired after reading it, but it's so well written.

This book is so sad. I shed so many tears when I read it for the first time. I can't forget it after reading it. I feel sad and sad when I think about this book. Its cruelty will not make people feel that it is torture for the sake of torture, but it will leave pain in my heart. I cried so much that I can't breathe [crying]

Liu Fulin was really upset, and the part about his death made him burst into tears and choked with sobs.

Compared to Da Mo Yao, as their descendant, this ending is obviously very regrettable, and it is quite depressing after reading it...

It's very good-looking, especially the vivid and vivid portrayal of Yunge. It would have been a hit if it was made into a TV series, but the director's casting was not good and the acting was not so vivid. It was too different from the characters in the book.

There is also a star for my Liu Fuling [crying] Why should such a good person have to die a good death [almost crying]

In fact, I wanted to read this book before but was worried... Then I started reading it. Indeed... Any plot about Yunge will remind me of the baby's face and Meng Jue's greasy white bangs~~ Sure enough, not choosing a good actor will affect the book. But after reading it carefully, it is really hard to calm down. I have been waiting for Brother Ling to recover from his illness and come back to life. Where can I hide and wait for Yunge?

Yunge, Liu Fuling, Meng Yu, Liu Xun, Xu Pingjun, etc., Every character is flesh and blood. There are joys and sorrows, but the happiest person is actually Brother Ling. He left, taking Yun Ge's love with him, and the rest of the people still have to face the cruelty of reality. I've read it for the second time. I watched it once many years ago. I won't read it for the third time. It's too painful.

I don't know why I couldn't help but feel sad when I saw the scene of Xu Pingjun's death. Liu Xun's favorite thing in his heart was Yunge. What was his feeling for Xu Pingjun? A substitute? Is it the next best thing? Maybe Liu Xun only loved himself. When he saw him sitting in his and Xu Pingjun's room with his coat wrapped around his coat at the end, he didn't know what to say. Is he missing Xu Pingjun or his old self when he was with Pingjun? He took Xu Pingjun's wish and didn't know that Xu Pingjun's wish was just to be an ordinary couple in the secular world with him.

After I finished reading, I suddenly didn't know what to say. I felt that the characters in the book were pushed to their own endings with the torrent of fate... Yun Ge took Brother Ling away from Chang'an and went to a distant place. She came from Brother Ling's poems and returned to the poems. Meng Jue planned his whole life, but in the end he left with regrets. He was not Xu Pingjun. He felt that if he held on tightly, he would not lose it. But in the end, he realized that the more he held on, the more it proved that this thing might not belong to you. How can the cracked white paper be completely restored? Ping Jun left with a debt, and Liu Xun's belated affection was as low as grass, but everything was lost. People are really complicated things. Huo Guang harmed Liu Fulin, but he often expressed worries about the country and the country in his words, which made people think that he was not that bad after all. Many things seem accidental, but in fact they are inevitable. It is impossible for Yun Ge to forget Brother Ling, and it is impossible for Meng Jue to find Yun Ge. It is impossible for Xu Pingjun to give up marrying Liu Bingji, and it is impossible for Liu Bingji not to become Liu Xun...

The author writes so much about love and hatred with his wonderful pen. There is no happy ending in the whole story, and I feel sorry for Meng Jue who still suffered a lot despite trying his best. However, if he had been more honest with Yun Ge, the result might have been completely different. I just hope that Meng Jue will survive when he falls into the Canghe River.

I feel that Meng Jue, an old fox🦊 shouldn't be killed so easily

When I first heard it, I didn't know what it meant. But when I heard it again, I already knew the meaning of the song. Thousands of twists and turns are knotted in the heart, and it is difficult to calm down after thousands of twists and turns. When wine enters the heart, sorrow will last longer, and it will be difficult to untie the knot in the heart.

I read another wonderful book! I like this cloud song very much Yun Ge was too cruel when he wanted to poison Meng Jue. I don't understand why he didn't reconcile with Meng Jue? Alas, the author is too perfectionistic. Only love that Shi 100% trusts is perfect, so when Yun Ge turned around and went back to find Liu Fulin, he said, "He and you are different people." In Yun Ge's heart, there was already a crack of trust in Meng Jue. I don't understand why Meng Jue chased from the Western Regions to Chang'an. Why did he hesitate to choose Huo Shi? The tragedy ended, and we were separated to death. We didn't want to be separated again. Why did Liu Fulin let Liu Xun enter the court as an official and lure the wolf into the house? Since Liu He could ascend the throne, why did he pretend to be ridiculous and cut off his and Hongyi's livelihood? Why did Meng Yu continue to stay in the court to die after Yun Ge left Chang'an? Since he already knew that Liu Xun killed Liu Fuling, would Liu Xun still keep him? He is said to be smart and powerful, but where is his intelligence? Where is the strength? Liu Xun is the person I really hate the most. He repays kindness with revenge, is ruthless, cruel, and has no chivalry at all. He poisoned Liu Fuling, killed his brother Heizi, and made Yun Ge lose his child. Just because he let go of Liu He who was no longer a threat to his imperial power, he alienated his first wife, and even threw Meng Jue off a cliff. It was really cruel.

While reading this book and researching information, I admire the author Tong Hua very much. He has a profound literary background, beautiful writing style, vivid characters, and the story based on history is very attractive, but it is so cruel that it makes people feel heartbroken. The comments in the article cursed Meng Jue many times, which is ridiculous! Only good books can make people unable to resist all kinds of comments.

It won't be played again, but it will be hidden in the deepest part of my heart [cry][cry][cry][cry][cry][cry]

Respecting history, the content is full of ups and downs. I actually read the novel to make up for the blind spots in history. Hahaha, it's great. You must read it. Sisters, it's definitely worth it.

She's super good-looking. I like Liu Fuling but it's a shame. In the end, Yun Ge was so miserable that her brother Ling didn't protect her well. I feel a bit regretful. Do you have any similar novels that can help me make up for the regret?

There are not many things that I can remember, but I can't let go of this sad love song. It hurts, but it still hurts, but it is short and brilliant, rich and long. Brother Ling, Yun Ge loves you like this. It hurts, but it doesn't hurt anymore. Thank you Tonghua, I really hope it happened...

Recommend. "Song in the Clouds" is a work that was adapted into a film and television, but the result of the film and television adaptation was not satisfactory. Now that I have read the original work, I deeply understand the complex meaning of history, palace battles, lust, hatred, etc. That the author wants to convey. Some people say that the author only likes to write tragedies, but I think the author actually likes to write about troubled times. Because in troubled times there are more idiots and resentful daughters, the love stories in troubled times are even more soul-stirring. But since we are in troubled times, the outcome is already doomed. Any emotion, bond, or hatred will eventually be lost under the rolling wheels of history. This can only be a tragedy. Each character is vividly portrayed in the book: Yunge, Meng Yu, Xu Pingjun, etc. All of them are the protagonists in their own stories, and some of them are poor people in troubled times.

We are not the kind of people chosen by God, nor can we guarantee that we are talented, but we are greedy and want to live in our own way, so we are all gritting our teeth and moving forward in entanglement and hesitation.

Tong Hua's writing style is as excellent as ever, the characters are vivid and full, and the plot is even more exciting, which makes people want to keep reading. Reading "Song in the Clouds" is like taking you into the long river of history, watching family struggles, regime changes, and power play. Finally, don't watch TV series! Don't watch TV series! Don't watch TV series!

A very sad story, one that is happy first and then sad. The author's sadistic pen is very sharp.

This book reminded me of the sweetness when we first got married. The love between Yun Ge and Liu Fulin was pure and moved me very much. I especially like the part where they meet in the desert. It feels like the first time my husband and I met, full of surprises and expectations. Although there are some sad moments in the story, overall it is still very good. Recommended to friends who like romantic love stories!

After reading it, my emotions couldn't calm down for a long time. It was because of Liu Fuling's heartache, Meng Jue's unwillingness, and Yun Ge's injustice. Each character is vividly and vividly created. Thank you for seeing such an excellent work!