Mine*****

After reading it for the fourth time, the ending of the tenant and Miss Tulip is the most satisfactory to me. Mi Gao and Yang Sisi suffered from the romance✋

Xiao Ai and Mi Cai have many similarities, and both can be said to be perfect women in men's hearts. Of course, my favorite is the more perfect rice color. But I think Tank's portrayal of Xiao Ai in "Tulip" is much more comprehensive, three-dimensional and vivid, and Xiao Ai's love for Jiang Qiao seems more real; while the portrayal of Mi Cai in "The Tenant (City in the Sky)" is more of a side foil, especially at the end. It would be perfect if the end (or postscript) of "The Tenant" could explain some details of Zhao Yang and Mi Cai's life after they met. Let's talk about Jiangqiao and Zhaoyang. The two of them also have many similarities. For example, they both have the same pursuit of pure love, which can be seen from their attitudes towards Chen Yi and Jian Wei. The difference is that Jiang Qiao's character is more realistic than Zhaoyang's. His life experiences may have been encountered by many people, allowing readers to relate to them; Zhaoyang's experience is a bit fantasy, bullying a girl, throwing away her quilt and other rogue behaviors can be tolerated (of course, it can also highlight the perfection of Mi Cai from the side). There are a lot of coincidences, and the storyline is a bit far from the reality of life.

This is the second book I have read on Tank. I am not going to read it again because it is so good that I can't help myself, but it is also so sad. Every heroine, Le Yao, Jian Wei, Chen Yi, and Jin Qiu, is heartbroken if they miss it. Jiang Qiao and Xiao Ai, Mi Cai and Zhao Yang are enviable, but it is sad and regretful that they cannot be together with other heroines! It's too cruel. It's not that powerful. I won't watch anymore.

This is the first book I've read by you... A sad life... You use very delicate writing to describe life~~~ I give you ninety-nine likes again

The author combines the moral and ethical fields and life that contemporary young people are most concerned about, and organically combines noble sentiments with simple and unpretentious life. The plot is moving and the language is fluent and attractive.

After reading The Tenant and then Tulip, I am tired and will not read Tank's book again. Tank's writing skills are profound and worthy of careful consideration. In my opinion, the overall story of Tulip does not surpass The Tenant (reader's personal opinion), but it does not affect Tulip's being a good story. I like Xiao Ai, but feel sad for Chen Yi. As a side note, it would be great if there was a sister like Yang Qu. This is the angel guarding Jiang Qiao.

After reading Tank's Miss Tulip, I was moved, but it was much calmer than the previous three books. The book is still as good as ever, and the evil heart is as evil as ever. I have to say that Tank's novels are still very able to capture the hearts of readers. The first-person narration is very immersive, making people unconsciously involved. The development of the plot happens naturally, making people feel the same. Except for the ending of Girlfriends, which is quite satisfying, I always felt like there was something missing in the other three films, and I couldn't enjoy it to the fullest, which was a bit of a pity. The new book is also being serialized, so I'm looking forward to it. Refuel the tank

As a super old bookworm, these novels are the most recognized among the urban novels I read. They are a breath of fresh air in this world of beautiful CEOs and soldiers. They are very close to many resonances in life, but it is very depressing to recognize people. It allowed me to see the cruelty of reality, people's helpless compromise with life, the unpredictability of human nature, and the love pursued by many characters.

It is a book that is very close to life. I saw myself in the male protagonist. My own insignificance in the big life, my low self-esteem and cowardice in society, my lack of confidence in facing life, and my confusion in facing the unknown future. I also want to have Xiao Ai who suddenly appears in my life to make me forget these things.

After reading a lot of comments, I realized that Jian Wei and Mi Cai, whom I had seen a long time ago and had a deep impression on, were both girls written by this author. I have relatively high standards for books, so I just skip most of the five-star reviews and those that are pertinent. I didn't expect that the limited number of urban emotions I have watched were all written by the author Tank. I give you a thumbs up! The writing is really good, but can the author make the heroine more ordinary and real next time? The perfect goddess in the writing makes people think about it, but she can't find it in reality! I read your novel almost without sleep for three days. In the dark night, I once felt that the good wife lying next to me was not as good as the people in your book. The emptiness and gap after reading it was really hard to let go.

The male protagonist I dislike the most in the three books is Mi Gao, Jiang Qiao is more likable, and Zhaoyang, what can I say, he is the most indecisive one. Everyone said Jiang Qiao was a scumbag, but I didn't see it anyway. He had no love for Jin Qiu, and he completely gave up on Chen Yi. He also endured pain for more than two years for Xiao Ai. Everyone said Jiang Qiao was the most pitiable in his life, but I felt that Mi Gao was the most pitiful. Zhao Yang had his father to assist him, and Jiang Qiao had his grandma and sister to assist him. On the other hand, Mi Gao had never been blessed or favored by his parents from the beginning to the end.

The story is plain and simple, but it makes people think about it. Although many holes have not been filled. But the topic is also very clear. Although the ending is very hasty. But the plot is very ups and downs. If Chen Yi is a tulip girl. Then Xiao Ai is the sunflower girl, giving the protagonist a beam of light in his miserable childhood. From the first moment I saw the title, I knew it was a sad story. But it's not a pity. The regret is only the details that are not found in life. And the courage to face the future.

After watching the tetralogy of Big Tank, my favorites are still Mi Cai, Zai Ye Zhi, Sisi Cha Xiaoqing, Chen Yi and Jian Wei, I feel a little bad, Jian Wei and Chen Yi, their miserable lives made me cry, Zhao Yang and Jiang Qiao are both sharpshooters, Jiang Qiao hits twice, Zhao Yang hits once, he is a sharpshooter.

As you wish, as you wish, as I wish, it will appear quickly. Ruyi, Ruyi... This is a book about human nature and the choice of love. People always have a physical level and a spiritual level. No matter how deep your spiritual love is, you may not be able to escape the shackles of the physical body. I feel very sorry for Chen Yi. Her character is obviously not like Jian Wei, but she still punished herself in her own way throughout her life. She dared to jump off the building for Jiang Qiao, but she didn't dare to give him understanding and tolerance when he needed it. This is the price of growth. She is willing to marry Jiang Qiao, who has nothing, but cannot marry Jiang Qiao, who has a successful career... As society progresses, we should rationally abandon the old idea of being in the same household and allow our children to love and choose love freely. This is the mission given to us by history. Because no amount of money can buy the warmth of the moment of family reunion. Xiao Ai is my favorite girl. She is smart and persistent, passionate and gentle. Only she can make the tulips slowly dim in Jiang Qiao's heart... To pursue free love and unscrupulous love, this is what they inspired me to do.

Chen Yi, this novel has been sublimated. This is not just a simple plot of a man and a woman meeting and falling in love. It is the author who tells a story about a group of people. Make it more real. Let it become the author's will that is difficult to reconcile, the male protagonist's will that is difficult to reconcile, and our will that is difficult to reconcile.

I've read every chapter and page of The Tenant! The writing is still very good, but I think it's a bit long-winded and over-emphasized, so I skipped reading this one. There will always be a tenant on the bookshelf, but it will never be read twice. The process is too depressing [face covering] [face covering]

I have read four books, and this one writes about the sinister nature of people's hearts and describes a lot of sincerity. I like this book better, and I like Mi Cai and Zhaoyang even more! But it's so depressing

The author is a person with profound life experience, and the characters he depicts are vivid and vivid. Chen Yi is the most authentic Miss Tulip, with silly and sweet love, selfless love, blind love, humble love, and falling in love with an inappropriate person. In reality, people like Qiu Zian are the most suitable for her; Xiao Ai, a girl who likes tulips, loves willfully and crazily, and the most hurt in reality is this kind of person; Jin Qiu, a woman who has an intersection with Tulip, loves utilitarianism and rationality, and is the real winner in real life.

I have read all of Tank's books, and they are indeed well written. Each book has its own characteristics. The emotional entanglement between the male protagonist and several confidantes is the most attractive. Now I have decided to read the love-hate relationship between Zhang Yixi and An Qi more than a dozen times!

I'm two-thirds of the way through this book, and today I suddenly heard a song called "Butterfly" by Tao Zhe again. As a person born in the 1980s, I also studied music in college. In fact, I am a long-time fan of Tao Zhe. I suddenly found that the lyrics of Tao Zhe's song are very suitable for the male and female protagonists written by Tank. From Yi Xi'anqi to Zhaoyang Micai to the tulip I am watching now, it is all because of sensibility and limits that I have created such fictional but real stories. Why haven't I experienced it?

The saddest part of this very interesting trilogy is "Waiting for You in Romance, Snow and Moon". Compared to "Waiting for You in Romance, Snow and Moon", Tenant and Tulip both really lived with the people they like. However, "Waiting for You in Romance" never had a comfortable life for even a second.

2022:0328 22:20, I finished reading it. It took two weeks to almost finish it. Like the tenants, I have many unspeakable emotions. I hope we are all well and become masters in life [Cool]

After reading The Tenant, I read this book again. The same love story is still full of regrets. Like The Tenant, I hope Zhaoyang can be with Jian Wei. In this book, I also hope that Chen Yi can be with Jiang Qiao. Indeed, many of the plots in the love story described in this book seem to be forced in, but this book also spends a lot of ink describing the touching family love, Miss Tulip

After reading Tank's book, I felt like I had experienced it myself. It had a strong sense of immersion, but it was also very heart-wrenching. However, if it wasn't heart-wrenching, it might not be as good to read!

I like Xiao Ai in the early stage the most, he is cute and cute. I feel that Jiang Qiao is the most miserable male protagonist. The character description is terrible, especially Chen Yi. Anyway, it is very miserable and tear-jerking. I wish all lovers in the world will finally get married!

In fact, this book gave me a very different feeling. He is like an old friend. The story between you and him may not be very exciting, but it is enough to move both of us. Jiang Qiao is not as heartbreaking as Zhaoyang. He only has a compromise with reality. All the bravery in life has been given to Xiao Ai, and Xiao Ai did not let him down. There is a beautiful answer between the two.

I have watched it from different angles. The first time I watched the love journey between Jiang Qiao and Xiao Ai, the second time I focused more on Jiang Qiao and Chen Yi's childhood sweethearts who were defeated by the secular world and their well-matched couple. The third time I watched it, I focused more on the mutual support and help between Jin Qiu and Jin Qiu.

The same life wandering on the edge of society, the same confusion and melancholy! Like the song "Rain Alley" by Dai Wangshu, a girl walks alone in a long and lonely rain alley holding an oil-paper umbrella. The elegance of the Jiangnan water town, love always makes people yearn for it, always makes people yearn for it, but it also always makes people melancholy and sad, and always makes people happy. It is short-lived, and the sadness of gains and losses always makes young hearts hesitate... Kobe Bryant can always touch the sentimentality of my youth, the most beautiful time in the past, and inadvertently touch the soft velvet-like memory of youth in my heart...

When I first started watching it, I saw a lot of people on Tieba saying it was not good, but I suppressed my emotions and finished reading it. Especially the experience after the music store was caught in a fire. To be honest, I felt quite deeply. It is really difficult to find a brave and sincere partner in this world.

The torture is definitely cruel, but the torture is very good. I am an old fantasy bookworm, but I still enjoyed watching it.