Shujian**

It's a very good book. I like the line in the book the most: "My master is dead, and the only thing left for the dead is his reputation. If you destroy my master's reputation, you will kill me."

This is not a novel, it is a story, it is a truth. After reading too many novels that pretend to be 13 and slap in the face, I calm down and let this "Tao" sublimate my heart.

An almost perfect outline, whether you are used to short stories, detail-oriented, layout-oriented, or like to make sweets, it is good. However, it is not that precise in any aspect. The length is too short and some of the plots are not so appealing. But overall, the shortcomings are not concealed, and it is worth recommending. The ending is not only regretful but also has some logical problems. The protagonist's final actions cannot lead to the final ending, but the previous part is indeed worth reading. Follow the book according to the situation.

The book is very good, and the pace is okay. It is similar to Doppo's style, but it is not as relaxed as Doppo. The content is too solemn. You must have a certain reading comprehension to read this article. This is a real novel, not a fast food article!

This is a book that allows you to calm down and read it carefully, feel the growth of Su Changan, experience the fearlessness of hundreds of thousands of soldiers in Xiliang, guess this unpredictable calculation, you can take a look at it, see how Su Changan "survive" in this troubled world, and take a look at the various characters in the book. This book has warmth, ruthlessness, parts that make you cry, and parts that make you happy. You should give it a try

It's very flavorful, and it's a lot higher than those mindless cool articles. Well... The stars are always there!

The rating of this book is too low. The plot is very good. Although the ending is a bit disappointing, the story is really perfect. There are laughter and tears, love and justice, pain and confusion. It is really well written. The protagonist Changan is a real person, with greed, desire, and things he wants to protect. It's amazing!

How can I put it this way? This book is very suitable for old bookworms. There are some parts in the middle that are not so good. Overall it is very good. If you want to read something interesting, please give it a try.

There are many shortcomings. First of all, there is insufficient foreshadowing in the previous text, and many plots are forcibly supplemented and explained in the later text. Secondly, the setting part is inappropriate, and the world view and structure have obvious flaws. Finally, some of the imitations and quotations are real failures, and the title of the book is also unintelligible. However, after reading it, there are indeed many resonant plots, the layout is self-defeating, and I personally think the ending is very good and beautiful.

This is a very depressing novel. The protagonist lives in conspiracy and calculation from the beginning to the end. The protagonist's sect lives from birth to death based on the four characters of "common people are the most important", and they all live under the calculation of the sect's ancestor. Everyone's life and death are in the hands of others. The biggest highlight in the book is the swordsman of the Chu family. For his own promise, he goes forward bravely and never returns his sword.

It's deep and good-looking. If you like to read cool articles, you can go.

I'm currently reading Chapter 8, which I find very interesting. It's a very real life of a young man, but Yu Duofang's characters don't have many characteristics at the moment!

Tomato has been reading the novel for more than two years and this is the first time I commented that the novel is very good.

To put it simply, this book is a bit unfinished, but it is well written, with a sense of calculation and growth, and a young man's transformation from childishness to maturity. He ran away for half his life and was still a teenager in the end. Having experienced setbacks, failures along the way, and an everlasting heart. And other book friends can resonate with Tianlan, the common people are the most important, and the feelings of family and country. Love it, love it

This novel can be considered a first-class novel, and the plot is described very delicately. The characterization of the characters is very profound. Su Changan gradually grows up in the great waves of human nature. The characterization of the male protagonist in the novel is very similar to our constant struggle in society. In the end, we become the people we didn't want to be.

This is the second time I read this book, a sadomasochistic love story, a unique ending, and a wonderful Hohhot plot. Everyone wrote it very well.

Not finished yet But I still can't help but want to say something I have to say, the author's literary talent is great The content of the work is also great When you taste it carefully, you can taste the philosophy in the words When you stare carefully, you can feel that the scenes described in the book are so vivid in your mind. You can't help but be sad sometimes Because...

The plot has no solution and doesn't drag out. Big boost to the author.

I didn't read it in detail, but I finished it. It's not a good ending for me, but it's hard to disagree with anyone. Even though I don't like the ending, I still think this is an excellent book. In fact, nothing changed, but it changed again. In the end, he still worshiped Mo Tingyu, but in my eyes, he was ignored by everyone, and he was definitely not the protagonist I liked. I think the transformation in the last two hundred and fifty chapters is very reasonable and I am happy to accept it. But the ending made me sigh. I think the ending is very good, because in my eyes tragedy can make a real classic, but I still feel a little bit sad after all, and it is an unforgettable book for me. Thank you author

I really like the characterization here, it feels very real and a bit touching. I really want to be a chivalrous warrior.

A good book, a good book that I haven't seen in many years. Fantasy but thoughtful, thoughtful, and innovative!

This book combines novice writing and general cultivation writing. It feels real but not so real. It is worth recommending.

I've finished reading it. I've been watching it for a long time. I finally finished it. It took about two weeks. First of all, I don't think there is any big problem with this book, but there is indeed a problem with the time and space setting. This is indeed a problem. If Su Zhao's existence is denied and Hong Luan was killed by Bai Yuanhe before, then the protagonist's situation will not be good at that time, and it is unknown whether he can achieve immortality. There is indeed a problem here, but it is really difficult to write about time and space, so it is normal for there to be flaws. But the characters written by the author are still great, and everything that needs to be written has been written. The character of the protagonist in the early stage is indeed difficult to accept, but I think the author's writing is not a piece of writing, it should be deliberately shaped, and it should be like this. I like that world and the simplicity, sincerity, and responsibility of Chang'an. Chang'an grows up in blood and tears, and we in life will also pay the price for our own growth. Many things in this book are very realistic and relevant. There are many characters in this book, and I don't know how difficult it is to understand, but I am quite emotional. There is touching, warmth, sadness, helplessness, regret, there are too many. This is not a very big world, but I like it very much. The world of martial arts and the humanities here are all great. They are flesh and blood, and the characters in this book are enviable. But I still feel sad for Beitong Xuan, feel unworthy for King Wu, feel sorry for Xiahou Suyu, impressed by the Three Thousand Swordsmen of Jiangdong, and also moved by the dull but sincere love, and feel sad for them to accept their passing calmly, and not only these, but also those inheritances. In fact, the author is quite good, and many things are very good. This book may be a tragedy in its own setting. But it's really great. That is the knight in my dream, I have seen it, and I have no regrets. Sincerely, this is the first time I have written so much to express my complicated mood at the moment. I wish you all a long life of peace and prosperity.

It's a rare good book. Although I burst into tears when I saw Yu Heng and Chu Xifeng's Soul Returns to the Sea of ​​Stars, I read the ending directly.

I have just read a few chapters, so I dare not make any comments. The writing is good, but the plot needs to be read more.

A good book, like Mao Niu's style.

It's well written, but it borrows too much from other novels. It's like rewriting the best parts of other people's novels, but it's still pretty good, even though I can see the shadow of many novels.

The creativity is good. I have read too many mindless fairy tales. This kind of novel is very good.

This book is very good. The protagonist goes from being ignorant to learning to think and learn how to live in troubled times and how to protect himself. He is brave, enthusiastic, kind, and affectionate. He does what he wants to do and protects the people he wants to protect, even if he offends someone more powerful than himself. This book also writes about a swordsman who is dissolute, loyal, and brave enough to face the swordsman of the Chu family in Jiangdong who never returns his sword.

After a glass of wine, the book was finished. The ending was good and the story was really good. The Jianghu in my heart has no pain or sadness. The artistic conception of this book is very high. The final reversal also returns to the beginning of the dream. Stranger, life is like a play. You have to dance whether you dance well or not. It's okay if you don't dance well in the first place, it's to prepare for the next blockbuster. If you dance well, you have to work harder. Finally, I wish you happiness 🙂 🙂 (I believe there are many students who will read this and still not try hard?)