Who Killed Her
by H
About This Novel
Worried about his depressed sister, traffic policeman Kang Zheng rushed to Tokyo, but what greeted him was his sister's body. The suicide scene that seemed unmistakable at first glance was full of flaws in Kang Zheng's eyes. He covered up the flaws and wanted the police to close the case with suicide so that he could personally find the murderer and take revenge. As expected, the police fell into the trap, and Kang Zheng's investigation was also carried out secretly. Only Interpol Kaga was full of doubts about this. However, no matter how hard Kaga pressed, Kang Zheng was determined to make a desperate move. The two slowly came closer to the truth during the contest... Who killed her?
What Readers Think
Rating
Community(0)
Official(90)Scraped 5d ago
There must be a difference in the way the two medicine bags were torn open. Junyi Tseng tore the first medicine bag (he was right-handed), and if the second medicine bag was torn open by a left-hander, then Sonoko still had the possibility of committing suicide. Kaga said that he could not let the case go unsolved, so he must have the evidence to make the decision. At the end of the novel, it was clearly stated that there was a murderer. If the two medicine bags were torn open in the same way (also by right-handers), then why couldn't Kaga convince the police department to become a task force? Because of Kang Zheng's testimony, Kang Zheng said that when he came to the house, there was an iron chain on the door. Kang Zheng used a tool to cut it open, and the whole room became a secret room. Kang Zheng was repeatedly forced to tell the truth because this was a prerequisite to prove that Sonoko was a homicide (the murderer needed to escape from the room after killing). "Kasagi handed the cup in his right hand to Kaiseko. Kaiseko smiled and said thank you, and took the paper cup. Yumba Kaiseko put her right hand on her cheek, her long nails glowing with beautiful luster." That proves that Kaiseko took the paper cup with her left hand, which can prove that Kaiseko is left-handed. I think this is only evidence, and it cannot prove that Kaiseko is left-handed. Just like in reality, when someone hands you coffee, which hand you hold it in takes it because it is convenient and cannot be said to be ironclad evidence. I remembered her gesture when she tore off the sleeping pills when she threatened Sekako with a knife, and the paper bag she threw away was in the trash can. In times of crisis, human instinct is faster than thinking. I guess Kang was watching her tearing off the medicine bag with her hands to prove that she was left-handed. She was a recessive left-hander like Sonoko. At that moment, he saw it with his own eyes. He told Kaga that there was no need for further identification. The murderer was that person. That person should be Tsukuda Junichi. If he was also right-handed, Kang Zheng would definitely not know who among them was the murderer and return to the same place again. He woke up in an instant because Shijiazi, who tore Kangzheng's medicine bag, revealed the most critical information in the case, and that information was that she was left-handed. Therefore, the murderer is Junichi.
Who killed her? There is suspense at the end, but luckily my brother didn't really kill the murderer. Although my sister has died, I still don't want to see my brother ruin his life for revenge.
I think it's more likely that it's Yuiba. After all, the disc is Yuiba's life-long secret. Sonoko can be exposed because of this incident this time, and she may be exposed because of other things in the future. So she may have been shaken after reading the letter, but in order to settle it once and for all and never have to be threatened in the future, she will probably choose to continue killing Sonoko. After Tsukuda saw the letter, he had no motive to kill Sonoko.
Finally, I remembered the foreshadowing of Kaga tearing up his business card. The murderer was Junichi, and both sleeping pill bags were torn by right-handers, so Sonoko was ruled out as committing suicide. The elder brother saw with his own eyes that Jia Shizi tore the bag of sleeping pills left-handedly.
A little thought. . .
First of all, based on logical reasoning, the murderer should be Tsukuda Junichi. The end of the book is not an open ending. The author has obviously confirmed the murderer. He did not specify it but just wants the readers to use their own brains to reason. So when everyone thinks that the murderer is Tsukuda Junichi, the murderer must be him, because if in the end there are different opinions, or it is completely wrong, then the ending will be meaningless, and Higashino Keigo will also be dumbfounded! However, Yumiba is still suspicious. After all, her suspicion has not been cleared in the end. There is no clear statement about why the plastic rope was dropped at the scene, the lipstick tissue and the crumpled advertising paper. It is not confirmed whether Tsukuda Junichi went back again, and whether he took a taxi was not checked. In the end, relying solely on left-handedness to judge the murderer feels a bit unconvincing no matter what.
Keigo Higashino's mystery novel has nothing to say
I felt great after reading it, but I was too stupid to guess the murderer. Later, after reading other people's inferences, I also believed that the murderer was that man. I thought this man was particularly disgusting.
Three different types of hair appeared at the scene, so two people appeared at my sister's residence on the day of the crime, and the murderer was undoubtedly one of them, two policemen, and two suspects. It's kind of interesting... Three torn medicine bags were found in the trash can in the house. Two of them were torn to the right, and the other was torn to the left. The sister was left-handed, so the murderer was her best friend and ex-boyfriend. I don't know if everyone has noticed that when my best friend attended the funeral, she picked up the handkerchief with her left hand, and the police at the scene also asked her to tear the medicine bag open to the left, so there was only one murderer, Junichi. I personally think that the reason why the murderer killed my sister is because my sister knew that Runyi was going to be with his best friend again, and she became emotional and threatened Runyi to save the relationship. Runyi couldn't bear it anymore and killed his sister, [but it's just a personal guess] The book is great! I really like Mr. Higashino Keigo's works, they are all valuable!
When will it be updated? If I were an adult, I could recharge as a member. Hey, I really have no money.
who killed her
At the end, I felt that it no longer mattered who the murderer was, and I hoped that no one would ever sell their souls to the devil. One thing I was very concerned about was that at first the tape covering the wires behind the garden fell off. Was Sonoko's death caused by electricity or sleeping pills? I'll look through it again
Rating
Community(0)
Official(90)Scraped 5d ago
There must be a difference in the way the two medicine bags were torn open. Junyi Tseng tore the first medicine bag (he was right-handed), and if the second medicine bag was torn open by a left-hander, then Sonoko still had the possibility of committing suicide. Kaga said that he could not let the case go unsolved, so he must have the evidence to make the decision. At the end of the novel, it was clearly stated that there was a murderer. If the two medicine bags were torn open in the same way (also by right-handers), then why couldn't Kaga convince the police department to become a task force? Because of Kang Zheng's testimony, Kang Zheng said that when he came to the house, there was an iron chain on the door. Kang Zheng used a tool to cut it open, and the whole room became a secret room. Kang Zheng was repeatedly forced to tell the truth because this was a prerequisite to prove that Sonoko was a homicide (the murderer needed to escape from the room after killing). "Kasagi handed the cup in his right hand to Kaiseko. Kaiseko smiled and said thank you, and took the paper cup. Yumba Kaiseko put her right hand on her cheek, her long nails glowing with beautiful luster." That proves that Kaiseko took the paper cup with her left hand, which can prove that Kaiseko is left-handed. I think this is only evidence, and it cannot prove that Kaiseko is left-handed. Just like in reality, when someone hands you coffee, which hand you hold it in takes it because it is convenient and cannot be said to be ironclad evidence. I remembered her gesture when she tore off the sleeping pills when she threatened Sekako with a knife, and the paper bag she threw away was in the trash can. In times of crisis, human instinct is faster than thinking. I guess Kang was watching her tearing off the medicine bag with her hands to prove that she was left-handed. She was a recessive left-hander like Sonoko. At that moment, he saw it with his own eyes. He told Kaga that there was no need for further identification. The murderer was that person. That person should be Tsukuda Junichi. If he was also right-handed, Kang Zheng would definitely not know who among them was the murderer and return to the same place again. He woke up in an instant because Shijiazi, who tore Kangzheng's medicine bag, revealed the most critical information in the case, and that information was that she was left-handed. Therefore, the murderer is Junichi.
Who killed her? There is suspense at the end, but luckily my brother didn't really kill the murderer. Although my sister has died, I still don't want to see my brother ruin his life for revenge.
I think it's more likely that it's Yuiba. After all, the disc is Yuiba's life-long secret. Sonoko can be exposed because of this incident this time, and she may be exposed because of other things in the future. So she may have been shaken after reading the letter, but in order to settle it once and for all and never have to be threatened in the future, she will probably choose to continue killing Sonoko. After Tsukuda saw the letter, he had no motive to kill Sonoko.
Finally, I remembered the foreshadowing of Kaga tearing up his business card. The murderer was Junichi, and both sleeping pill bags were torn by right-handers, so Sonoko was ruled out as committing suicide. The elder brother saw with his own eyes that Jia Shizi tore the bag of sleeping pills left-handedly.
A little thought. . .
First of all, based on logical reasoning, the murderer should be Tsukuda Junichi. The end of the book is not an open ending. The author has obviously confirmed the murderer. He did not specify it but just wants the readers to use their own brains to reason. So when everyone thinks that the murderer is Tsukuda Junichi, the murderer must be him, because if in the end there are different opinions, or it is completely wrong, then the ending will be meaningless, and Higashino Keigo will also be dumbfounded! However, Yumiba is still suspicious. After all, her suspicion has not been cleared in the end. There is no clear statement about why the plastic rope was dropped at the scene, the lipstick tissue and the crumpled advertising paper. It is not confirmed whether Tsukuda Junichi went back again, and whether he took a taxi was not checked. In the end, relying solely on left-handedness to judge the murderer feels a bit unconvincing no matter what.
Keigo Higashino's mystery novel has nothing to say
I felt great after reading it, but I was too stupid to guess the murderer. Later, after reading other people's inferences, I also believed that the murderer was that man. I thought this man was particularly disgusting.
Three different types of hair appeared at the scene, so two people appeared at my sister's residence on the day of the crime, and the murderer was undoubtedly one of them, two policemen, and two suspects. It's kind of interesting... Three torn medicine bags were found in the trash can in the house. Two of them were torn to the right, and the other was torn to the left. The sister was left-handed, so the murderer was her best friend and ex-boyfriend. I don't know if everyone has noticed that when my best friend attended the funeral, she picked up the handkerchief with her left hand, and the police at the scene also asked her to tear the medicine bag open to the left, so there was only one murderer, Junichi. I personally think that the reason why the murderer killed my sister is because my sister knew that Runyi was going to be with his best friend again, and she became emotional and threatened Runyi to save the relationship. Runyi couldn't bear it anymore and killed his sister, [but it's just a personal guess] The book is great! I really like Mr. Higashino Keigo's works, they are all valuable!
When will it be updated? If I were an adult, I could recharge as a member. Hey, I really have no money.
who killed her
At the end, I felt that it no longer mattered who the murderer was, and I hoped that no one would ever sell their souls to the devil. One thing I was very concerned about was that at first the tape covering the wires behind the garden fell off. Was Sonoko's death caused by electricity or sleeping pills? I'll look through it again
