I Killed Him
About This Novel
"Detective Kaga 5: I Killed Him" is another "guess the murderer" style work by Keigo Higashino that allows readers to solve the mystery. A wedding that was supposed to be grand ended abruptly in a series of accidents. The groom's ex-girlfriend committed suicide by taking poison, and the groom died of poisoning at the wedding. The police wanted to characterize the case as coercion to commit suicide for love, but Kaga followed up step by step and identified three suspects. They are all full of murderous intentions towards the groom, but they have perfect proof that they cannot poison him. Faced with the intricate poison capsule conspiracy, Kaga must make the man confess: "I killed him!"
What Readers Think
Rating
Community(0)
Official(78)Scraped 3d ago
The murderer is Naoyuki Suruga
What needs to be solved is the whereabouts of the capsules. Zhunzi purchased the capsules and there should be 12 capsules in total. A total of 6 capsules were found on the table after the suicide. The suicidal man took one. According to the suspect's description, Junko put two pills into Makoto Hodaka's pill box before committing suicide. Takahiro Kambayashi took one pill away, fed one pill to the cat, and threw the other pill away. Yukiyo Kaori took 1 pill and handed it over, and Suruga Naoyuki took 1 pill and gave it to Kamibayashi Takahiro to hand over. So far, 1 pill is missing. But at this time, we can guess that the only ones who have the opportunity to take this one are Yukiyo Kaori and Suruga Naoyuki. Let's talk about Hodaka Makoto's little medicine box, the order in which it changed hands on the wedding day: Miwako Kambayashi – Kaori Yukiyo – Ms. Nishiguchi – Naoyuki Suruga – waiter. This time, Nishiguchi and the waiter can be eliminated based on Kaga's reasoning. Finally, Kaga said that one of the three items had the fingerprints of not everyone present. It should have existed. It is conceivable that the item must be a small medicine box, because the author had previously laid the groundwork and said that the small medicine box was very unique and was bought by Makoto Hotaka and his ex-wife. So it stands to reason that there should be more than two small medicine boxes. After all, the medicines used by two people will not be exactly the same, at least it is unrealistic to mix them. There is a medicine box, the one commonly used by Makoto Hotaka. Due to frequent use, I am afraid that the fingerprints on it have become complicated and unclear. However, the other one has been kept with Naoyuki Suruga as a relic (as mentioned earlier, Makoto Hotaka sent the relics of his ex-wife to Suruga), so the fingerprints of Makoto Hotaka's ex-wife will definitely be retained. Moreover, Suruga himself said that after giving the pill box to the waiter, he asked about the pill box and learned that the pill box was not given to Makoto Hotaka but left at the door. Knowing this, it is not difficult to think that Suruga had every opportunity to replace the pill box, so Naoyuki Suruga was the real murderer.
If you have read more than 10 books by Keigo Higashino, give me a thumbs up o(≧v≦)o~~It's great
The murderer should be Miwako, because only Miwako is a bystander in the whole article, and we read the article from a God's perspective, but Miwako's motives are harder to guess. Is it just to give everyone the impression that she is a normal person? However, the criminal motives of almost all criminals in Keigo Higashino's works are bizarre. Personal opinion, don't comment if you don't like it.
Fingerprints of items on three photos 1. People touched by Miwako's package in the original text: Miwako, Nishiguchi Eri, Yuki Sasa 2. People touched by the original text of Medicine Bottle: Hodaka, Takahiro Kambayashi, Miwako 2. People who were touched by the small medicine box (specifically refers to the one that was once placed in Hodaka's house) in the original text: Hodaka, Eri Nishiguchi, Miwako, Yukisasa, Suruga, and the waiter. Persons unrelated to Hodaka-related cases who appeared in the article 1. Nishiguchi Eri: Got back Miwako's bag containing the medicine bottle from the beauty salon, took the small medicine box from Yukisasa, put it in the bag and gave it to Suruga. 2. Waiter: Get the small medicine box from Suruga and place it at the door of the groom's lounge. 3. Hodaka's ex-wife: Things have always been kept at Suruga's house, and there is a high chance that some of them may be mixed with Hodaka's old medicine bottles (for example, when they broke up, the bottle of medicine was not eaten and the bottle was not thrown away) or a small medicine box (Hotaka's small medicine box was bought with his ex-wife, there is a possibility that he bought a pair) If Suruga is the murderer, it just fits Kaga's words, but there are too many missing fingerprints on the ex-wife's medicine box. As long as they investigate, they will know that they have been swapped. It can only be said that Suruga did not expect to find the ex-wife's fingerprints. Although the police would not know where the small pill box came from without his ex-wife's fingerprints, but for Kaminbayashi, who had rarely seen the appearance of a small pill box before, or Yukisasa, who was not known to have had a close relationship with Hodaka, Suruga was obviously the biggest suspect. At first glance, it seems that the poison capsule poisoning is a chain, but if the poison killing is replaced by the pill box, it will be much clearer. I guess the murderer might be Suruga.
Want to know who the murderer is?
When you choose to read this book, the author's cover has already told you the answer.
Directly below is the murderer
Because Hui Gaocheng was getting married, he put all his ex-wife's things in the studio. It was Junha who took his ex-wife's pill box, put the poison capsule in it, and replaced the whole box of pills at the door... Because he wore gloves during the wedding, there were no other people's fingerprints
You can look at the answer like this
Kagami said, then the answer will come out. Hemeizi said, then please tell me. At the end of the book, then the murderer is you. I think it corresponds. The murderer is He Meizi
The murderer may be anyone. It is impossible to specify a person, anyone will be the murderer. This is a novel that exposes human nature. From the following narrative, it can be seen that almost everyone wants Hotakajo to die, so it was the ugliness of human nature that killed Hotakajo (but he also brought the blame on himself)
The final ending, the finishing touch.
The words of the murderer are like the title. First person me.
Kneel down and beg the murderer
So who is it⊙ω⊙?
Rating
Community(0)
Official(78)Scraped 3d ago
The murderer is Naoyuki Suruga
What needs to be solved is the whereabouts of the capsules. Zhunzi purchased the capsules and there should be 12 capsules in total. A total of 6 capsules were found on the table after the suicide. The suicidal man took one. According to the suspect's description, Junko put two pills into Makoto Hodaka's pill box before committing suicide. Takahiro Kambayashi took one pill away, fed one pill to the cat, and threw the other pill away. Yukiyo Kaori took 1 pill and handed it over, and Suruga Naoyuki took 1 pill and gave it to Kamibayashi Takahiro to hand over. So far, 1 pill is missing. But at this time, we can guess that the only ones who have the opportunity to take this one are Yukiyo Kaori and Suruga Naoyuki. Let's talk about Hodaka Makoto's little medicine box, the order in which it changed hands on the wedding day: Miwako Kambayashi – Kaori Yukiyo – Ms. Nishiguchi – Naoyuki Suruga – waiter. This time, Nishiguchi and the waiter can be eliminated based on Kaga's reasoning. Finally, Kaga said that one of the three items had the fingerprints of not everyone present. It should have existed. It is conceivable that the item must be a small medicine box, because the author had previously laid the groundwork and said that the small medicine box was very unique and was bought by Makoto Hotaka and his ex-wife. So it stands to reason that there should be more than two small medicine boxes. After all, the medicines used by two people will not be exactly the same, at least it is unrealistic to mix them. There is a medicine box, the one commonly used by Makoto Hotaka. Due to frequent use, I am afraid that the fingerprints on it have become complicated and unclear. However, the other one has been kept with Naoyuki Suruga as a relic (as mentioned earlier, Makoto Hotaka sent the relics of his ex-wife to Suruga), so the fingerprints of Makoto Hotaka's ex-wife will definitely be retained. Moreover, Suruga himself said that after giving the pill box to the waiter, he asked about the pill box and learned that the pill box was not given to Makoto Hotaka but left at the door. Knowing this, it is not difficult to think that Suruga had every opportunity to replace the pill box, so Naoyuki Suruga was the real murderer.
If you have read more than 10 books by Keigo Higashino, give me a thumbs up o(≧v≦)o~~It's great
The murderer should be Miwako, because only Miwako is a bystander in the whole article, and we read the article from a God's perspective, but Miwako's motives are harder to guess. Is it just to give everyone the impression that she is a normal person? However, the criminal motives of almost all criminals in Keigo Higashino's works are bizarre. Personal opinion, don't comment if you don't like it.
Fingerprints of items on three photos 1. People touched by Miwako's package in the original text: Miwako, Nishiguchi Eri, Yuki Sasa 2. People touched by the original text of Medicine Bottle: Hodaka, Takahiro Kambayashi, Miwako 2. People who were touched by the small medicine box (specifically refers to the one that was once placed in Hodaka's house) in the original text: Hodaka, Eri Nishiguchi, Miwako, Yukisasa, Suruga, and the waiter. Persons unrelated to Hodaka-related cases who appeared in the article 1. Nishiguchi Eri: Got back Miwako's bag containing the medicine bottle from the beauty salon, took the small medicine box from Yukisasa, put it in the bag and gave it to Suruga. 2. Waiter: Get the small medicine box from Suruga and place it at the door of the groom's lounge. 3. Hodaka's ex-wife: Things have always been kept at Suruga's house, and there is a high chance that some of them may be mixed with Hodaka's old medicine bottles (for example, when they broke up, the bottle of medicine was not eaten and the bottle was not thrown away) or a small medicine box (Hotaka's small medicine box was bought with his ex-wife, there is a possibility that he bought a pair) If Suruga is the murderer, it just fits Kaga's words, but there are too many missing fingerprints on the ex-wife's medicine box. As long as they investigate, they will know that they have been swapped. It can only be said that Suruga did not expect to find the ex-wife's fingerprints. Although the police would not know where the small pill box came from without his ex-wife's fingerprints, but for Kaminbayashi, who had rarely seen the appearance of a small pill box before, or Yukisasa, who was not known to have had a close relationship with Hodaka, Suruga was obviously the biggest suspect. At first glance, it seems that the poison capsule poisoning is a chain, but if the poison killing is replaced by the pill box, it will be much clearer. I guess the murderer might be Suruga.
Want to know who the murderer is?
When you choose to read this book, the author's cover has already told you the answer.
Directly below is the murderer
Because Hui Gaocheng was getting married, he put all his ex-wife's things in the studio. It was Junha who took his ex-wife's pill box, put the poison capsule in it, and replaced the whole box of pills at the door... Because he wore gloves during the wedding, there were no other people's fingerprints
You can look at the answer like this
Kagami said, then the answer will come out. Hemeizi said, then please tell me. At the end of the book, then the murderer is you. I think it corresponds. The murderer is He Meizi
The murderer may be anyone. It is impossible to specify a person, anyone will be the murderer. This is a novel that exposes human nature. From the following narrative, it can be seen that almost everyone wants Hotakajo to die, so it was the ugliness of human nature that killed Hotakajo (but he also brought the blame on himself)
The final ending, the finishing touch.
The words of the murderer are like the title. First person me.
Kneel down and beg the murderer
So who is it⊙ω⊙?
